
scottosan
Well-known member
I really like this combo. Had the mids of an A5, top end of an A2 and the power of ceramic. No mud to be had.
Last edited:
I never touch my tone controls, though the pickup is mid heavy, but not in spiky way. On the clean side, you can really tell it’s slamming the front end harder than it’s ALNICO relatives. And yes, not as compressed as ceramic. I never find the tone charts especially helpful for mid voicing. Low mids can be perceived as bass and high mids can be perceived as treble.Not much info on the 8.. Only reference I could find is the SD Alternative 8. I like that SD gives you a basic EQ graph for the response of the pup.
Seems like your clip has a lot of mids but is solid and less compressed than a Ceramic.
Did you find that you turned the mids down on the amp??
Not yet. I’ve mainly been trying to get them out on the street for real world feedback and development. I will likely have a batch of several models pre made and available as a Black Friday stupid deal and official kickoff, but I’m cutting it close. I still have work on my website to do.You sell these pickups?
Gotcha, hopefully everything works out as those pickups sound amazing.Not yet. I’ve mainly been trying to get them out on the street for real world feedback and development. I will likely have a batch of several models pre made and available as a Black Friday stupid deal and official kickoff, but I’m cutting it close. I still have work on my website to do.
Not sure which one of their pickups you got, but I might be able to make some recommendations from thereI was unaware of the A2 long vs Short. Had picked up a pariah A2 based pickup and to be honest, it felt a little loose to me and I wanted more definition in the low end. High end was good but for me, I need it tight for riffage. That might explain what I was hearing. Might also be the way it was wound. I had heard good things about those pups but again as you mentioned, in the wild, every player and every rig is going to be different
Not sure which one of their pickups you got, but I might be able to make some recommendations from there
Not yet. I’ve mainly been trying to get them out on the street for real world feedback and development. I will likely have a batch of several models pre made and available as a Black Friday stupid deal and official kickoff, but I’m cutting it close. I still have work on my website to do.
At 16.8k/A2 and hand wound, I would expect less mids and more bottom and top end than a JB2. Because of the lack of the mid hump and more bottom and top being let through, I could see how a A2 might feel a little loose in the bottom. I’ve always felt that A2 is more bassy, but is slow compressive way vs A5 being more immediate. I personally don’t like A2 in a high output hand wound pickup because it doesn’t need the mids balancing out like a machine wound pickup of the same specs. I think a cheap magnet swaps might get you closer to where you want to be in the Patina.It was the "Patina" . Described like this:
Delivers a hard driving rock tone with a “velvety” punch. The warmth of the Alnico 2 Special magnet balances out the midrange providing a defined low end with singing highs.
The Patina is an excellent pickup for blues, rock and metal.
Sounded promising but I don't hear the defined low end so much.. it seems softer and rounder. So the velvet singing highs sure which are cool but maybe a bit top heavy in the bass which makes it seem like it doesn't cut as much. It sure doesn't cut like my JB2. That thing is crunchy and defined yet rounded. Maybe I just got lucky with that pup as it was someone on this forum that swapped magnets in a regular JB but it sounds incredible.
At 16.8k/A2 and hand wound, I would expect less mids and more bottom and top end than a JB2. Because of the lack of the mid hump and more bottom and top being let through, I could see how a A2 might feel a little loose in the bottom. I’ve always felt that A2 is more bassy, but is slow compressive way vs A5 being more immediate. I personally don’t like A2 in a high output hand wound pickup because it doesn’t need the mids balancing out like a machine wound pickup of the same specs. I think a cheap magnet swaps might get you closer to where you want to be in the Patina.
Same here, got the SD Alt8 in an older LP Studio and it's amazing. The midrange sounds full and the upper-mids are like a less harsh JB. Works great. The pickup in Scottosan's video sounds excellent, really love the balance of it. Powerful and full but not muddy or harsh at all!Duncan Alternative 8 is probably the best sounding pickup I have in a Les Paul right now. Love it.