Bigger sounding 36th Anni Bridge?

Kapo_Polenton

Kapo_Polenton

Well-known member
I don't like many Dimarzios but I like the 36th anniversaries. In one of my LP clones, I have 500K pots and Dimarzio 36 anni neck and bridge. Neck sounds fantastic in this guitar. Hard to beat. the bridge is nice and crunchy and tight but it can feel a bit light in "girth" ( every woman's complaint) and a bit thin on the high end. I'm looking for something that is tight and crunchy like it but bigger sounding and fuller in the highs for lead playing. What pickup am I describing that is easy to find and doesn't cost half the price of a Charvel?
 
Sounds to me like what you might need is to try out an alnico II magnet in the 36th anniversary. Its going to round off the highs and increase the lows.

If that is not the ticket, then the Suhr Thornbucker II would be my suggestion. Similar output range, alnico II magnet for that warmer top and fatter bottom. Duncan APH-II could be a good choice also.
 
Check out Planet Tone pickups. The DiMarzio touts itself to have more of a 50s quality to it.

If you want something that is like a vintage humbucker, but in modern HD, I would recommend a Legacy pickup. I have an open faced Legacy and it is tight, crunchy, but has that top end vintage warmth and body to the notes.

Very clear and articulate with top end presence and body.

I like my Jem with an EVO 2 in the bridge but find it lacking in many ways compared to the Legacy in my Tele. The pickups have an EQ difference overall, of course, with the Alnico V in the Planet Tone adding a midrange to the top, that gives it that vintage warmth mentioned above.

The legacy is essentially a high powered 1959 PAF - and it delivers.
 
Sounds to me like what you might need is to try out an alnico II magnet in the 36th anniversary. Its going to round off the highs and increase the lows.

If that is not the ticket, then the Suhr Thornbucker II would be my suggestion. Similar output range, alnico II magnet for that warmer top and fatter bottom. Duncan APH-II could be a good choice also.

I was just looking at those a 20 min ago.. I remember that I used to have an epiphone with Slash Alnico II in them and that bridge sound was kick ass. I think that might be what is in order here.
 
Anyone try those tonerider pickups on Amazon? Great prices on those things and very good reviews. I'm willing to pay for a set of duncans but these seem to sound pretty good to my ears.
 
I don't like many Dimarzios but I like the 36th anniversaries. In one of my LP clones, I have 500K pots and Dimarzio 36 anni neck and bridge. Neck sounds fantastic in this guitar. Hard to beat. the bridge is nice and crunchy and tight but it can feel a bit light in "girth" ( every woman's complaint) and a bit thin on the high end. I'm looking for something that is tight and crunchy like it but bigger sounding and fuller in the highs for lead playing. What pickup am I describing that is easy to find and doesn't cost half the price of a Charvel?

@DiMarzio Media what do you suggest?
 
Seymour Duncan Whole Lotta Humbucker with the rough Cast A-5. It's the only other PAFish pickup that is equal to my 78 model SD. PDC recommended these so I tried one on a whim and I really like it. If you don't like A-2 magnets in PAF's check the WLH out.

I've had Dimarzio 36 anniversaries in the past and the SD WLH is just better.....of course IMHO.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: PDC
Anyone try those tonerider pickups on Amazon? Great prices on those things and very good reviews. I'm willing to pay for a set of duncans but these seem to sound pretty good to my ears.
They are decent but I prefer a good Duncan or DiMarzio by a bit. See if you can find a Duncan Custom on the cheap.
 
They are decent but I prefer a good Duncan or DiMarzio by a bit. See if you can find a Duncan Custom on the cheap.
I have a box of pups sitting around...spares, time to roll them through! I just found an old slash alnico 2 duncan. Short lead but i can make that work. Not zebra but I can live with it.
 
I have a box of pups sitting around...spares, time to roll them through! I just found an old slash alnico 2 duncan. Short lead but i can make that work. Not zebra but I can live with it.
The old slash 2's have flat mids.

That being said, if you want to see how a magnet swap might change your pickup, this is one of the best comparison vids I have found:

 
Grok says:

Based on your description—keeping the tight, crunchy response of the DiMarzio 36th Anniversary bridge (DP223) while adding more low-end girth for body and smoother, fuller highs for singing leads in an LP-style guitar with 500K pots—you're describing the:

Seymour Duncan SH-1 '59 Model (bridge version).

It's a vintage PAF-voiced humbucker that's widely praised for delivering that exact upgrade: beefier overall mass without muddiness, rounded treble sparkle instead of thin ice-pick harshness, and excellent articulation under gain for leads that cut through cleanly.

### Why This Pickup Fits
- **Tight & Crunchy Foundation**: Like the 36th Anniversary, it's got a focused low end that stays punchy and responsive (no flab under distortion), but it avoids the "light" feel by emphasizing fuller bass and low-mids for a bigger, more authoritative crunch—perfect for palm-mutes or riffing that feels substantial in a mahogany body.
- **Fuller Highs for Leads**: The '59's alnico 5 magnets and scatterwound coils give highs a velvety, harmonic-rich bloom rather than the brittle edge you mentioned. It's ideal for expressive bends and sustains that sing without fizz, especially in the bridge position where leads need to soar over a mix.
- **Balance with Your Neck Pickup**: It pairs beautifully with the 36th Anniversary neck (DP103), as both are low-to-medium output (around 7.5–8.1k DCR for the '59 bridge), keeping coil-splitting viable if you use it. Many players swap in the '59 bridge specifically for this reason in mixed setups, noting how it complements the neck's warmth without overpowering cleans.
- **LP-Specific Vibe**: In Les Paul clones or Standards, the '59 shines for classic rock/ bluesy leads (think early Clapton or Slash territory) while handling moderate overdrive without losing definition—exactly the "bigger sounding" step up from the 36th's leanness.

### Availability & Price
It's super easy to find—stocked at every major retailer like Sweetwater, Guitar Center, Reverb, or Amazon, often with quick shipping and nickel/silver covers to match aesthetics. Street price is $100–$120 new (well under $150), with used ones going for $70–$90 on Reverb/eBay. No exotic sourcing needed, and it's not in Charvel-proprietary territory (those often run $200+ for custom-wound stuff).

If you want to audition it first, search YouTube for "'59 bridge vs DiMarzio 36th Anniversary" clips in Les Pauls—they highlight the girth/highs difference clearly. Drop it in, and it'll feel like the natural evolution of what you already love about that guitar. If it doesn't click (unlikely), the return policies at those sites are solid.
 
Anyone try those tonerider pickups on Amazon? Great prices on those things and very good reviews. I'm willing to pay for a set of duncans but these seem to sound pretty good to my ears.
I don't remember all of the names of the pickups but I've got three different sets of Toneriders and they're great. High quality and punch above their weight class. They can't sell double creams in the US anymore but there are some UK retailers who will ship them to you and they're about the same price as they are here (if you care).
 
Back
Top