I've had numerous TSs and SD1s. I've had the VFE Standout, Airis Savage, Suhr Koko(s)...
My favs are the Timmy and Klon.
Timmy is a super versatile pedal. Clean boost, colored boost, stand-alone od, It's a tool everyone should have. It's the Buck knife of od's.
This Klone has a weird volume pot, so I have to crank it more than usual for the standard volume boost. However, it is the best sounding one I've had out of Tumnus, Ikon, Centura, KTR, Conspiracy Theory, PCE AF, Stud...couple others I can't remember the names of. From boosting an overdriven amp, to adding the most beautiful sparkle, to being a stand-alone od for a Fendery amp, the Klon is choice.
The Wampler Belle is fast becoming one of my favorite od's. I could describe it, but I'll just say, go grab one and play with it. You'll find a use for it. Easily on par with the Timmy and Klon.
The Cherry Bomb is my fav treble booster so far. I've had Diamond Marquis, Fulltone Ranger, couple others. The only one I still want to try is R2R. Cherry Bomb adds a very organic boost to an overdriven amp. The tone knob helps navigate between cocked wah and too much bass. One of my fav pedals. Super cool into a Vox, or other overdrives. Also, very good behind other fuzz pedals for shaping tone and creating chaos.
Super surprised by the Dano EQ. Damn. Who knew. And I've used it all this time in the effects loop or behind other pedals to get the sound I wanted. It's a bad bitch.
Greer Lightspeed is like the sprinkle of cinnamon on your toast. It doesn't do much, but what it does is oh so tasty. Best at the end of the chain, to funnel overall volume and eq.
Analogman DS1 is probably my fav dirt into a clean amp. It's 80s metal to 90s grunge greatness.
Spaceman Polaris is niche, probably best into a clean amp, and stacking with other pedals. I've had great luck with it into a crunchy Vox or DRRI, and in use with some chaotic fuzzes to shape the eq.