Yes, I really didn’t care for 5150 album tones either, But interestingly, I wonder if I would like fair warning even more if it had that VHII guitar tone?
Another-words, I sometimes wonder whether I like the ‘fair warning tone’ because I am being swayed by the music itself and not the actual guitar tone…
I saw Van Halen in 1981, 1984, 1986, 1991, 1995, 1998, 2012…
The worst live tone I ever heard from Eddie (for me) was the 1995 tour.
The best Marshall tone was 1984 concert.
The best Post Marshall tone, by a mile, was 1998 with his Peavey 5150II amplifiers. The juice he had that night, those amplifiers sounded like they were going to catch fire at any second…
It’s all subjective though, I guess nobody’s right or wrong.