Thanks man!
Honestly, you just repeat and repeat and repeat. Eventually you learn what works and what doesn’t in a mix, even without hearing the other instruments. It’s also very hard to judge a guitar tone that is single tracked when you are going to double track it and spread it out across the stereo field like modern productions ( heavy stuff anyways) do.
As far as having to feel like you always need to brighten them up , I almost always brighten my guitars in some way shape or form, but it realllyyyy depends on what’s going on in the 3-6k area. Again, this just takes time to figure out and reference, reference, reference . What I CAN tell you is, most IR’s are far, far too dark to work in any mix I like anyways. If you feel you need to constantly brighten them up, you need to start looking at your IR choice. Put a hi/low pass at 65hz and 12k or so (just real gentle to start) and start looking through IR’s. Forget the dual mic shit until you can get a sick tone with just one 57. If it’s not sick with just a 57, adding another mic isn’t gonna fix it, I promise you.
Every one of these IR’s I’m using in this track for the most part is titan audios IR’s, and I swear by them: mostly because I know who Zach’s mentor for production is. Zach is in the band whitechapel, and has learned virtually everything and used the same gear to make these as engineer mark Lewis.
All this is great, but if you can’t hear it , you can’t fix it. I’ve got a pretty great sounding room with a great monitoring setup ( genelec 8351s, 7370 sub), and that makes all the difference. Honestly, nothing else matters until you get that right. You don’t gotta go that crazy to get a great sounding guitar tone or mix though of course .
These are just some of my initial thoughts on this. I could talk about this for hours. But constantly reamping everything you can and getting a feel for what works and what doesn’t in a mix is a great way to learn. Eventually you’ll start to hear and be able to fix things immediately or pick an IR you know is gonna be sick immediately . It does take a lot of time though in my experience. And I sure as hell am no professional either, I just try stuff and read until I have beaten a dead horse, and then I kinda maybe learned something from whatever I did….maybe lol.