Upon further examination I'm finding the green one doesn't push the amp as much like it's lacking in volume. The black one is a heavier guitar and the tone knob is kinda wonky so I'm thinking new pots in both should do the trick plus these guitars don't need the push pull tab nonsense.
I always play with the tone and volume knobs all the way up I almost never turned down the tone knob I think one might be better than the other possibly
Okay so I have two guitars same wood same pickups one of them sounds more aggressive than the other one sounds spongy and not as sharp. The only differences are one has tens one has a nines. Also I possibly had the volume pot replaced in the black one. Here are the pictures of the control...