My two main guitars lack top inlays. I think, especially for a rosewood, ebony, or other darker fretboards, it has a very classy, refined look--almost like an orchestral instrument. The only time I ever find myself wishing I had the inlays is when the other guitarist or the bassist are trying to figure out what I'm playing. That said, I'd miss having top dots but could probably get used to it pretty quickly. Only thing that would throw me off is switching between different guitars with different scale lengths in that regard.