fek":2v9huhb1 said:
Well the PT was #2 on my list but has now gone to #1. What updates are coming with the new version?
Thanks for the offer Rayneman. I thought you had one locally. You have had just about every amp out there so how does the PT hold up against them in your opinion?
Not sure on the new PT...it seems to have been in "the works" for an awfully long time. I think, but am not sure, that it would be branded as a "Suhr" amp and have that cosmetic design as well (i.e. tubes up). I think its also supposed to be MIDI controllable, if that's an issue. I could be wrong.
Anyway, after having the PT100 for awhile, and this is just me, I couldn't even look at the Ecstasy I had. I had that XTC for years and years, swore I'd never get rid of it, but the PT100 made it easy to sell and not miss it.
Against a Herbert, well, two very different amps and its cool to have both. Honestly, the PT100 covers nearly everything one could need, except the most vicious of super-heavy metal tones. If I had to get rid of the PT or the Herbert, the Diezel would go, simply because the PT100 is just more of my tone at this point.
I've owned two SLOs, one with a depth mod and one without. I tried to like those amps (twice in fact) but while they are "legendary" I guess and having been able to use them live and loud they do deliver, they just ended up not for me. To compare the SLO to the PT100, and again this is just my opinion, the PT100 is just a better amp when you consider 1) clean tones (staggering improvement compared to SLO) 2) FX loop (galactic/collosus/ridiculous improvement over the SLO) 3) Dirty tones...this is where most people would differ. I don't think there's a wide variety of heavy tones from the SLO, while with the PT you have feedback/presence/whomp to tweak the amp beyond the front panel EQ along with the 2 gain "channels" that share EQ. The PT is pretty usable at low volumes, while the SLO had me fiddling with minute changes in EQ endlessly to try and find something that sounded just right at volumes that weren't insane. Maybe my cabs were wrong for the SLO (V30s), but I just never bonded with those amps and it certainly may be because in all seriousness I play more at home than on stage or at a loud band rehearsal, so I'm not using the amp in its "element."
I don't know, one should definitely play the Soldano for an extended period of time before forming an honest opinion of it. Its one of those holy grail type amps that if you get one, you nearly automatically profess a great love for it, and say its the best amp ever, etc...I have done this over and over again. I took me a long time to say out loud that my XTC was not the best amp ever...SLO not so long but the result was the same.