If it's an older shiva, the effects loop level is CRAZY hot.
You need to build yourself a special "Signal ducking" cable. (It's a combination of resistors wired into the plug of a cable which will bring the level down to pedal, or rack, level. See instructions here: http://www.bogneramplification.com/customshop/ShivaLoopConstruct.php
Then, instead of plugging back into the RETURN jack, plug into the BOOST AMP IN, then run a cable from BOOST AMP OUT into the RETURN.
I think it's a 2006 model so it should have the updated loop. I've run a DD-6 through the loop for delay and it sounds great. I had a Soldano that had a crazy hot loop as well and no pedals at all would work without sounding terrible.