Thanks dudes! The Herbert records much better with this Apogee one, the VH4 sounds compressed in the rosetta stoned video.
I did do things differently when I recorded with the VH4, I pushed the volume up a tad more so the mic was getting hit harder.
Also have to remember that I don't have a mic mount for the Apogee yet, so it is hanging by the usb cable wrapped around a mic stand hanging in front of the speaker.
It's possible that I didn't have the mic in the best place when using the VH4...
Right now the mic is in place to use the Herbert, tomorrow I will plug the VH4 into that cab to see the different with the same exact speaker.
Oh and yes I am using Mesa 4x12 oversized slant cab's.
For the Adam Jones tone, I have to say mixing both herbie and the vh4 together sound amazing!
Recording I think right now the herbie sounds more like Tool.
Still to early to tell!
I really couldn't choose one of the two, when I run only one at a time now I feel like half my rig is missing and it sounds incomplete tone wise.
When I record I still run both amps at once and mic one of them as the Apogee one is mono.