WCR Godwood vs MCP Detroiter........my impressions

  • Thread starter Thread starter troublehead
  • Start date Start date
troublehead

troublehead

New member
I've used an uncovered Godwood in my LP for quite awhile now. I've always loved this pickup because its so juicy and fluid with no overbearing spikes anywhere. Makes everything real easy to play and also easy on the ears. However, recently I've felt like the GW was too compressed for heavy rhythms. My other guitarist uses ceramic mag pups and I was sounding a bit "soft" in comparison. He was doing all the "chunking" and I was doing the "thudding".

Up until now, my only experience with MCP was the Afwayu in an alder super strat. I didn't really give it much of a chance but my initial impressions were not good. Its been awhile so I don't remember exactly what I didn't like about it. But I ended up selling the guitar and the buyer loved it.

I decided to take a chance on a covered Detroiter set to replace the GW and the Slash A2P in the neck. There is very little info on the Detroiters on the net, so I was a bit concerned. I just read as much as I could find and took an educated guess on what I was going for soundwise.

I got them in last night, hit a chord and they smacked me right in the face :rock: The initial "Wow" factor was greater than any pickup change I've ever made. They are real difficult to describe as they seem to have something odd going on........but in a good way. For example, they are smooth but they sound really pissed off. The articulation is MUCH greater than the Godwood and they have an edge to them that sounds perfect for what I'm playing. They seem to have less output than the Godwood, but that may also be a result of the really "open" sound they have in comparison. End result is that I seem to be playing a more "vintage" pickup, but it sounds heavier..........if that makes sense.

The Detroiter neck is 100 fold clearer and more articulate than the Slash neck. The Slash pup was great for liquidy, sustainy, lead work but wasn't good for much else. My amp doesn't have a clean channel, so I needed something I could roll down the volume on the neck and make do on the fly for cleaner chord work. The Detroiter suited this perfectly.

I have read that the Detroiter has a P-90ish vibe and I can hear that to some extent. I always equate P-90's as pissed off and snarly and the Detroiter is definately that...........but its still smooth. I don't know how that happens because those two traits are usually mutually exclusive from my experience. IMO, these will suit everything shy of death metal.............and do it extremely well.

In a nutshell........tighter, more open/articulate, nastier, more mids than the Godwood.........all without sounding harsh.

Anyway, I just wanted to thank Wade for the killer pups and the raw nickel finish looks killer as well :thumbsup:

Obligatory pics
001-5.jpg

006-5.jpg
 
I bought a TA guitar second hand that had the Detroiters installed. I was very suprised at how much I liked them. Seemed to do well with all but the heaviest styles of music. I ended up selling the guitar but +1 for the MCP D's.
 
I have been reading up on different pickups and have been considering the detroiters and the slash as I am thinking of replacing the stock shaw paf bridge hb in my 84 lp custom as it has been getting a bit noisy and need a little more output. I dont play metal but do play hard rock an like a crunchy but still vintage based hot rodded tone, would u reccomend the detroiters or the slash for the bridge position or any others?? Thanks
 
joepete77":3asm7tyh said:
I have been reading up on different pickups and have been considering the detroiters and the slash as I am thinking of replacing the stock shaw paf bridge hb in my 84 lp custom as it has been getting a bit noisy and need a little more output. I dont play metal but do play hard rock an like a crunchy but still vintage based hot rodded tone, would u reccomend the detroiters or the slash for the bridge position or any others?? Thanks

the bare knuckle riff raff and black dog pickups are great options as well

the riff raff is the most open sounding bridge pickup I've ever played
not really a true fat sounding PAF, but it sounds thicker than the tim shaws and it's got a lot more edge to the top without getting spikey
twangy, clear and versatile
on distorted chords it leaves some "air" in the mids that I've never heard from any other pickup

I loved the motor city 2nd degree black belt as well, but I just sold it today :aww:
 
I would've never guessed the Detroiter was tighter & nastier than the Godwood :confused: . I guess I can cross it off my list to try.

joepete77":2njpbiyq said:
I have been reading up on different pickups and have been considering the detroiters and the slash as I am thinking of replacing the stock shaw paf bridge hb in my 84 lp custom as it has been getting a bit noisy and need a little more output. I dont play metal but do play hard rock an like a crunchy but still vintage based hot rodded tone, would u reccomend the detroiters or the slash for the bridge position or any others?? Thanks

The Detroiters are killer pickups man. You can't wrong with them for what you mentioned and sound absolutely huge doing it too. I have them in my Hamer Vector & it makes that guitar sound bigger than my Les Paul if that tells you anything. The "feel" is spot on too. The only knock I give them coincides with what Drkorey said. They leave something to be desired for the really heavy stuff.

I've never played the Black Dogs, but the clips on the Bare Knuckle site are killer.
 
I have a 2ndDBB in the bridge. I love this pickup but there are something things I'd like to change about it, but not at the expense of what it does well. Perhaps that isn't possible. I want to try a Detroiter. From what I have read about it, it is what I'd change about the 2ndDBB if I could. Wade talked me into to trying an Angel Dust, which is a very tight, big sounding pickup. Very cool and most people would likely prefer it for heavier more modern type stuff. However, it has a different thing going on than the 2ndDBB. I still prefer the 2ndDBB.

I'm still going to try out a Detroiter, but I accept that it may not replace the 2ndDBB.

Does anyone have any experience with Wade's single coils?
 
The initial "Wow" factor was what got me into his Torque pickup, now the Angel Dust. Just great for classic rock, blues to hard rock. Very versatile.
 
Back
Top