E
MrDan666":3gh2b8if said:For what it's worth, those Marshall branded V30's do NOT sound like regular Celestion branded V30's.
If your first V30 experience is with those, then you really need to also try the regular Celestion V30's.. As in, the ones you buy as replacement speakers. Big difference. I love regular Celestion V30's, but i absolutely hate the Marshall branded V30's.
RoidRage":1gkk0sid said:MrDan666":1gkk0sid said:For what it's worth, those Marshall branded V30's do NOT sound like regular Celestion branded V30's.
If your first V30 experience is with those, then you really need to also try the regular Celestion V30's.. As in, the ones you buy as replacement speakers. Big difference. I love regular Celestion V30's, but i absolutely hate the Marshall branded V30's.
I TOTALLY Disagree![]()
I find Regular V30's Especially Chinese ones Iritatingly BRIGHT, and RASPY.... Can't stand them...
MrDan666":ugz22svl said:RoidRage":ugz22svl said:MrDan666":ugz22svl said:For what it's worth, those Marshall branded V30's do NOT sound like regular Celestion branded V30's.
If your first V30 experience is with those, then you really need to also try the regular Celestion V30's.. As in, the ones you buy as replacement speakers. Big difference. I love regular Celestion V30's, but i absolutely hate the Marshall branded V30's.
I TOTALLY Disagree![]()
I find Regular V30's Especially Chinese ones Iritatingly BRIGHT, and RASPY.... Can't stand them...
That's fair enough, and tone is always subjective. But the regular V30's definitely sound different to the Marshall V30's. That's the only point i was making in my post.. The o/p may prefer the regular V30's over the Marshall V30's.. Or it could be the other way round. Best thing is just to try both and then decide, since they both sound very different![]()
50MkII":3hgsuikx said:Those posted pics of the Marshall V30's are UK made.
Dare I complicate things further? I was told by a Mesa Rep. that Celestion makes them their Vintage 30 speaker for them and are physically and tonally different than the Chinese ones(e.g. riveted vs. glued). I contacted Mesa and when asked about the tonal differences the person responding stated they were not sure or do not know if there is a tonal difference. When I contacted Celestion, Dr. Decibel simply replied saying it is a special build for them and could not discuss it due to "customer confidentiality". Interested in trying both versions out sometime in the future.
50MkII":2zjh2qnt said:Those posted pics of the Marshall V30's are UK made.
Dare I complicate things further? I was told by a Mesa Rep. that Celestion makes them their Vintage 30 speaker for them and are physically and tonally different than the Chinese ones(e.g. riveted vs. glued). I contacted Mesa and when asked about the tonal differences the person responding stated they were not sure or do not know if there is a tonal difference. When I contacted Celestion, Dr. Decibel simply replied saying it is a special build for them and could not discuss it due to "customer confidentiality". Interested in trying both versions out sometime in the future.
RoidRage":5j1ssmy5 said:I have done all this a LONG time ago... Yes they sound different, Yes the Mesas Sound better than Reg V30's
I have 5 different Versions, and COMPARED THEM ALL!!!
MESAS ARE MADE IN ENGLAND, AND USE 444 CONES... BUT THEY DO NOT USE THE ALNICO MAGNETS OF THE MARSHALLS.
Mesas... Are Slightly Smoother, and Less Bright than Standard V30's BUT they Still Have The RASPYNESS of the Ceramic Magnets.
I RATE THEM AS FOLLOWS:
1- EARLY 80'S & ROLA V30'S MADE IN ENGLAND
2- MARSHALL V30'S MADE IN ENGLAND
3- MESA V30'S MADE IN ENGLAND
4- V30'S 90-2003 MADE IN ENGLAND
5- V30'S CURRENT CHINESE
RR