At what point is a clone not a clone?

[8len8]

I see a lot of threads about clone amps. For example, small plexi style clones.

The thing is, an amp has many characteristics, so how many need to be duplicated to consider the clone a clone?

In the plexi example, I consider a plexi to have a certain tone, openness, low end thump and high end raspinesses. If there’s a 5W clone that only emulates the tone and raspiness, should it really be called a clone?

Just pondering - I don’t really have a horse in this race.

 

[glpg80]

A clone isn’t a clone when it’s all original.

By definition that means made in the factory during the proper time period which validates its authenticity. Legally no one can stamp a serial number on a chassis less they want to get sued by Marshall. That’s what makes them clones.

 

[zendra]

I see a lot of threads about clone amps. For example, small plexi style clones.

The thing is, an amp has many characteristics, so how many need to be duplicated to consider the clone a clone?

In the plexi example, I consider a plexi to have a certain tone, openness, low end thump and high end raspinesses. If there’s a 5W clone that only emulates the tone and raspiness, should it really be called a clone?

Just pondering - I don’t really have a horse in this race.

...just as well...a horse can not be a clone of an amplifier...no matter how it sounds...