BK Black Dogs VS. Suhr Aldrich PUPs?

[reverymike]

I'm a long time Aldrich user in my Les Paul, but as we all do now and then. . .I'm considering a switch.

How does the Aldrich compare to the Black Dogs?

Which one is fatter sounding for single note stuff?

 

[nigelpkay]

I've never played the Suhr Aldrich, but the Black Dog is the fattest of the fat for single notes. As it says in the BKP description, something like "notes have a lot of weight behind them", it really is true. The LP I put them in was a little plinky on top and it really fattened it right up.
Be prepared for a lot less output. It's a hot PAF, but takes gain like no other, so if you have a high gain amp, you can go right from vintage to cranking it right up and the Black Dog won't fall apart.

 

[reverymike]

Amps are old Marshalls, Bogner 101b, SLO, 92 Dual Rec, and a Friedman Modded Marshall.

Sounds like it could be what I'm looking for!

Anyone else able to chime in?

 

[PlayAndersons]

I put Black Dogs in my Les Paul after removing EMGs and after lowering the bridge pickup a lil it's working. What's funny is I've been wondering what the Aldrichs would sound like in there but I'm thinking I went the right direction. Played it yesterday it sounded good through my rig.

My amps are similar: Friedman BE 1OO, SLO, Bogner 100b, Trem-a-verb and I'm using a multiple amp set up. Really like it through the Friedman...

 

[ptgold]

SLO, XTC and a Friedman BrownEye ?!?! thats like the Holy Trinity right there!