Old thread is old I suppose.
I’d say anyone hating on Kirk should watch “Murder In The Front Row”.
I think beyond whether or not we think Kirk is an amazing player, he’s solidified his spot in the legacy of both metallica and the Bay movement in general.
Seems no one from that time doesn’t have a great history with Kirk. He taught Holt how to play, and seemed to be one of the biggest guys pushing bands to get moving in the beginning.
Was he better than Mustaine… nope, but he was embedded in that scene. He’s got too much history in Metallica for them to ever move him on.
As said, he ain’t the best lead player but he’s the best lead player in Metallica. I think he’s worthy of the respect of most, simply due to his part in the history of American thrash.