Yeah man, I think most of us agree on what a legend George is for sure. After Randy passed, and EVH started getting more into keyboards and whatnot, George really took the torch and with Dokken became THE breakout hero of the mid to late 80's for that style of playing. It was George, Warren, and Jake really at that point, and all 3 brought it in a big way but I always put George at the top. I remember looking for a Charvel after reading in the liner notes of Tooth and Nail that he used Charvels at that point, I still have it to this day, an 84 tiger stripe (not really a bengal pattern like his guitars, but as a kid I still felt like I was channeling some George through it!)
And all of us who saw him back in the day and then over the years know...even by his own admission, he never played stuff consistently live. And when he was off, it could be a bit of a mess. But when he was on....I'll use the word again, untouchable. I think Jeff Pilson made a similar remark not too long ago as well. One of the coolest things I got to do was shoot the breeze with George a few years ago for awhile over a gear transaction, just me and him talking like regular gear heads. He was funny as heck, telling me stories of the old Dokken days and it was just a cool vibe. So he's still the MAN to me...even if I can't connect with what he's been doing musically for a long time.
I think all we're talking about is how the legends who are still with us and still playing are doing these days. Vai does a crazy one handed thing recently and you can't help but give the thumbs up, and he's 60 if we're talking age. Paul Gilbert's younger at 54, but decides he wants to play slide recently and it is crazy good. Doesn't change George's legacy for me one bit, or respect that he's still out there playing, and obviously he has always been a very different player than a Steve or Paul. But the difference is that most stuff he posts these days (and for a while really) doesn't click for me like those examples. And I don't think age has been as big a factor as how he is choosing to do things like dial in tone, as Kapo said how he is choosing to pick, etc.
I just think he's in a different headspace and honestly that goes back into the mid to late 90's when he was trying to adapt to the times. And yet again, on any given night the old George can appear. I remember seeing him in the early 2000's opening for Yngwie, and while I would always catch George live when I could, I had felt for awhile that his best days might be gone. Couldn't be more wrong, he was ON that night...easily as good as his late 80's/early 90's "peak".