Personally, I can’t stand a pickup that has soft/loose/compressed feel. But that’s just me. I like the feel of the second degree black belt, touch sensitive, yet firm in tone and feel. Tight and articulate, with a nice punchiness that with the addition of high gain is absolutely crushing. Even with high gain when you slam a chord there is a clarity to the notes. Love that stuff. The soft and loose feel, I don’t like that but I know some players like it a lot.
I don’t know about your models and the characteristics of each of them. Do you have something firm and touch sensitive in feel, and tight, punchy and articulate in tone? In low to medium output? Everyone on here says you deliver the goods. I can always make room for a pickup builder who delivers the goods as there are so few. I have been disappointed many times after I hear someone speak of a new bitchin builder of pickups. I hear their info and get fired up, and almost always, I find I am disappointed.
I had a steckel and it came with the candy pickups. He borrowed a real 60 burst and he said the pickups were the best he ever played. He had Duncan make a replica set of those and he said that they are almost identical. They sounded great and felt great also. Low output but epic for hi gain. Cleans sounded swell also.
If you have anything in the realm of either of those or something else like them, please let me know. I would be very interested in the acquisition of a set.