Ok, so I just got off the phone with Bogner. Apparently, because of it's design, the Shiva has massive bias-drift depending on the volume of the amp.
If you bias it at idle, after warming up for 5 minutes, it'll read super low (like mine).
If you bias it running it cranked, it will read 10+ HIGHER on the meter.
The tech said that lots of guys (like me) don't know this, crank up the bias, and then blow up their amp when they go to crank it. Not good. I'm probably going to set mine back to factory specs and just play it.