FourT6and2":1kuvb26s said:
scottosan":1kuvb26s said:
FourT6and2":1kuvb26s said:
scottosan":1kuvb26s said:
ledvedder":1kuvb26s said:
Which one of these 10K resistors is the PI dropping resistor?
It is not shown on your pic. It’s further upstream.
On a separate note, I noticed Nic ommitted the dropping resistor between the PI filtering and the subsequent stage filtering caps on both the 50 and 100. Doesn’t make sense
These amps don't need it. You could add one in and try it, but your preamp voltages in V1 and V2 will be too low.
It’s not just about voltage drop. The resistors also serve as the bifurcation of the filtering at different stages along the B+. Generally the PI node has dedicated filtering a dropping resistor after the screens and a dropping resistor after the PI and before the preamp. In the current configuration 50uf of the board mounted dual can is paralleled with 50uf of the chassis mounted cap with no standard dropping resistor between the 2 intended filtering stages. I don’t think this was by design because the same could be accomplished with a single 100uf cap. If keeping the B+ Up was a concern then compensate on the plate resistors. Of course
The current layout works but I think it was not intentional
I've asked Nik about this in the past and he said it was by design. Yes, one half of the main cap and one half of the board cap are in parallel with one end at ground and the other at V2b/PI/choke. But the amp doesn't really need it. What would it accomplish in this circuit?
We know the amp works as is. Let's just say it's just unusual.
Merlin talks about this in his book and the importance of decouple between stages. Because each stage shares the same supply there is always a degree of feedback/feedforward between stages. Keep in mind that signal emits form the anodes. Because the power supply does no have a zero source impedance audio currents will travel across it and appear on a shared power supply. This can lead to excessive LF distortion or oscillation. Decoupling the filtering isolates the signal as well as smoothing and filtering. Even looking at the of the Fortin Cali which this amp is based off or any Marshall schematic for this matter as well as Fenders, all have filter coupling between the PI and preamp.