Out of those two go with the Taylor.
I had a Taylor 414 CE-R, great sounding guitar, but I eventually sold it.
I rarely if ever play acoustic so I keep a MIM Martin GPCRSGT around.
It is all-solid sapele back & sides with a Sitka Spruce top Martin made in Mexico.
I've had a few of its American Counterparts and this one played better than they did so I kept it.
Back then it was $999 with a Hard case included.
I've owned it longer than any other guitar, I even put locking tuners on it, lol.
They still make a version of it, but it is called something else.
It will be a lot less $$$ than the all-solid Taylor.