shreder75":14n7mq3m said:
BUT to take this one step further....there's people who know theory for days and yet can't seem to pick out one fucking good note on the whole goddamn guitar....lol
give me someone with a working knowlege of the guitar with a good ear who can improvise something tasty and interesting over a guy who knows how to voice every chord in the book and knows the inner workings of every scale created yet can't play anything palatable any day of the week =)
One has zero to do with the other. Especially for Rock guys. But knowing the note names and intervals is NOT knowing theory, it's a start.
Also chord voicings and how a scale is build is merely a start. Wanna have a laugh have a guitarist explain modes...99 out of 100 will tell you something that makes perfect sense to them but is useless and wrong. This is where ideas like if you know theory you can't find a good note come from. the theory of harmony is where shit is at. When you know how a progression functions then the "good" notes are what you pick by choice, not chance. As for the ear...doh...but again there are too many guys that really have shit for ears, couldn't tell you a F# chord without comparing the notes on fretboard, couldn't tell a minor from a major, etc...
Bottom line,if you hav to ask what key is this in when you hear something guitar in hand you need an ear tune up...