Kirk Hammett doesn't suck. Period.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Steinmetzify
  • Start date Start date
Steinmetzify

Steinmetzify

Well-known member
I really don't get all the hate for this guy.......are people really that mad at him?

The average music buying public(that aren't guitar players)don't even know what a vibrato is, let alone if it's off pitch.

They don't know what a wah pedal is, let alone if it's overused or not.

Someone said in another post that it comes off as jealousy, and that's all I can see.......this board is full of a nice mix of guys that play classic rock, metal, nu-metal, classical, and pretty much every other kind of guitar based music out there.

But what I see most as far as hater threads and off the cuff comments go is hating on Kirk.

His vibrato might not be the best. He might overuse his wah(HIS wah, you know......the one with his fucking NAME on it, that sells all over the country and the world? Yeah, that wah).

So fuckin what? Do all the haters play at their absolute BEST everytime they pick up a guitar? Really, do you? Is he not allowed to have an off night, and off month, or even an off year? He's been doing this for 30 YEARS, man......he's been doing this longer than some of the guys on this board have been ALIVE, and he's written some of the best music in his genre.

Can ANY of you haters say the same? Did any of you write the solo for Sanitarium? The rhythm for Disposable Heroes? The clean passages for Fade to Black? Have ANY of you written what was arguably the 3 or 4 most influential albums in metal and gotten them certified platinum without ANY radio play or video rotation?

Or....you know....are you just playing in your mom's basement or at a local club for 53 people who are so drunk and desperate for a night out that you could pretty much play anything and they'd cheer you because after paying the $4 cover to see your 'band', you actually think they've showed out to see you, and your super tight vibrato and your controlled as hell wah pedal? :no: :no: :no:

What if every single time you posted a vid here of your playing all anyone ever said was that you overused your EMGs, or that your vibrato blows......every single time?

Are you all so bitter and angry about the music career or lack thereof that you have, that the only outlet that you have is to start a hater thread about a fellow musician?

Take it for what it's worth......I think constructive criticism is all good......but just bashing something over and over for no other reason than you don't like it or are jealous of it is just lame in the highest sense of the word.

And that's what all the bashing around here is. Lame.

Music is supposed to be, above all.....fun. I think maybe some people here have forgotten that.

Rant over, bash on.
 
So much Kirk butthurt :cry:

To the OP, I essentially agree with you, but this forum isn't made up of the "average music buying public" so the comments are going to be more critical by nature...most of the commenters actually have an idea what they're talking about as opposed to displaying blind fanboyism.

I like Metallica myself, but I also recognize Kirk as being an average player at best. That's not necessarily a bad thing either...I prefer a lot of average players over a lot of the virtuosos/shredders. It all comes down to personal tastes.

As Badronald mentioned, I'm sure Kirk could care less what a bunch of forum guys have to say about him...he's done pretty well for himself with his limited abilities ;)
 
I never, ever, get tired of listening to And Justice For All.
 
I think its an inevitable thing... you hit a certain level of success and then every minor flaw or weakness is amplified and blown out of proportion.
 
hammett is fine ..im more worried about lars suckin balls
 
Maybe he does it on purpose to be relevant after all these years! How many of these threads have we seen :lol: :LOL:
 
@Rupe.....I get that part of it, bro......I do. And everyone is entitled to their opinions, whatever they may be.

The part that gets me: sure, these guys can sit in their bedrooms playing Kirk solos at double speed and never make a mistake, and do it for hours on end......but can they invent those solos in the first place? No, they can't.....if they could, they'd just do it instead of playing keyboard warriors who spit negative whiny crap about whether his stuff is in key.

That's the part that bothers me.....the butthurt and the jealousy part of it.
 
His playing perfectly suits their music.

I'll leave it at that.
 
I was never a fan of Metallica but I'd never say the guy sucks. There are guitar players I like, and ones I don't. Its all personal taste.

all my friends loved them in the 80s.....I tried, and couldn't stand the band. Then they came out with the LP with all the hits like sandman........ I thought, hey they finally learned how to write songs, and all my friends hated them because of that LP. Go figure.
 
Steinmetzify":9c882w8z said:
That's the part that bothers me.....the butthurt and the jealousy part of it.
Get over it, Kirk sucks IMHO. The fact that he is wealthy or has sig gear does nothing to prove that he has talent

What he does is by its very nature, open to critique. Not liking what he does doesnt make anyone butthurt or jealous, that very notion is completely and utterly absurd..
 
Kirk sucking or not....... all I know is my playing sucks. :cry:
 
To the OP.... you pretty much typed what I have always wanted to type in Kirk hater threads, but have just always been too lazy too...

It's jealousy to an extent plain and simple, the only part of your rant that I wanted to comment on is obviously a guitar player is going to be more critical than the average listener about another GUITAR players playing... but I agree at the end of the day it just doesn't matter, Kirk is pretty much the poster child for the proof that being the best player in the world, having the best gear, or whatever, doesn't mean your gonna "Make it"... and while a lot of dudes here would say that's not their reason for arguing that Kirk sucks, they are full of shit if they told you they wouldn't trade places with him...

....for the record I don't even really like Metallica LoL
 
Gainzilla":3mp5otx7 said:
Steinmetzify":3mp5otx7 said:
That's the part that bothers me.....the butthurt and the jealousy part of it.
Get over it, Kirk sucks IMHO. The fact that he is wealthy or has sig gear does nothing to prove that he has talent

What he does is by its very nature, open to critique. Not liking what he does doesnt make anyone butthurt or jealous, that very notion is completely and utterly absurd..

There's nothing to get over.....this isn't something that defines me as a person and the OP took me about 15 seconds to write. Kirk doesn't suck, IMHO.

All due respect Kage...because I respect your skills and you seem like a good guy...a critique by definition is a detailed analysis and assessment of something.

30 people saying his wah is overused or his vibrato sucks is not a detailed analysis.

I'm not saying that because he's wealthy or has sig gear makes him talented, I'm saying that I dig what he's done in the past and am just astonished at the amount of hate on here for him.....seems like every other day there's another thread about him being bad.

That's all I was saying with the OP(with some other things thrown in for good measure :D ).
 
He is not a great guitarist by any means. He did write some killer, catchy and innovative stuff though. But that was long ago. He hasn't really had a reason to be inventive or innovative in years. Metallica are one of the biggest bands in the world and they can ride that train for many years to come. However, that doesn't mean that they are still putting good music out. They haven't put anything out that mattered for many years, but again, they don't have to. Kirk isn't very good. Many of us here outgrew his playing years ago, but that doesn't mean that he didn't have his time and contribute greatly to metal, because he did.

Success does NOT equal talent. Ashley simpson is not talented but she had way more success than 99.99% of us will ever have. Kirk himself says that teenagers love his guitar playing but most people grow out of his style. His playing fits Metallica's music, period.
 
Gainzilla":1mwb5hfq said:
Steinmetzify":1mwb5hfq said:
That's the part that bothers me.....the butthurt and the jealousy part of it.
Get over it, Kirk sucks IMHO. The fact that he is wealthy or has sig gear does nothing to prove that he has talent

What he does is by its very nature, open to critique. Not liking what he does doesnt make anyone butthurt or jealous, that very notion is completely and utterly absurd..

This x10000000000.

Kirk sucks. FULL STOP. Metallica are a bunch of has-beens. Listen to SODOM if you want to hear some real thrash.

-C
 
Kirk was good back in the day and I still like his playing. :thumbsup:
 
I'd like to go back in time and see how many Kirk haters had a man crush on him in the 80's.
 
Back
Top