Kirk Hammett doesn't suck. Period.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Steinmetzify
  • Start date Start date
Bob Savage":3djec1xr said:
Gainfreak":3djec1xr said:
Real sorry about that face comment on youtube. If it makes you feel any better, I look stupid all day long.

LOL... you and me both my friend.

Correction though, he didn't say stupid, he said MOST ANNOYING FACES EVER! My response was "If you think that's bad you should see me walk, or talk, or ride a bike, or take a hike..."

:hys:

I have been kindly reminded many times by my girlfriend about the silly faces I make when I play guitar live or otherwise :D

With that said, You have got to love the youtube comments! If anyone needed to guess the average IQ of mankind, one only needs to go to youtube and read the comments. :hys:
 
i met Kirk when i went to NYC the first time back in 2004 or 2005. he was really nice and we hung for a bit at Chelsea Guitars. Anyway, i still think he's boring as a player, still better than me but his playing does nothing for me.
 
SLOgriff":sfrqlcv7 said:
The thing I like best about Kirk is his hot wife! :thumbsup:

kirk-hammett-and-wife.jpg


seriously? she looks like Jimmy Page. :D
 
Bob Savage":h5loqrnm said:
Gainfreak":h5loqrnm said:
Real sorry about that face comment on youtube. If it makes you feel any better, I look stupid all day long.

LOL... you and me both my friend.

Correction though, he didn't say stupid, he said MOST ANNOYING FACES EVER! My response was "If you think that's bad you should see me walk, or talk, or ride a bike, or take a hike..."
:lol: :LOL: :lol: :LOL: :lol: :LOL:
 
Bob Savage":3a7jdfwr said:
Soundguy213":3a7jdfwr said:
The whole point is respect.
People on the Internet lack it on a staggering level.
It's surprising coming from those you all want to be judged fairly when it comes to their own music. You can say it's my opinion stated as fact, but your missing the point a little.

With this, I agree. It's people in general that lack respect, however, any communication medium that is for the most part anonymous seems to bring out the worst in people.

Quite frankly, I've had all kinds of terrible things said about my playing, writing and tone, and I couldn't care less. In fact, I don't even care whether it's a genuine opinion or somebody just being a jerk. Heck, somebody actually posted on my youtube site that my face looks stupid when I play. Um, so?

Totally agree. There seem to be an awful lot of angry miserable people behind the anonymity of the internet. That being said, I once had some doosh at a gig ask me, "What's with that face you make when you play? It looks like you're taking a dump..". I said, "No, that's my holding in a dump 'til break face"......... :lol: :LOL:
 
If Kirk didn't have a permanent place in the pantheon of guitar players, this thread would have been 4 posts long...
 
spirit7":1i4wcf6e said:
Gainzilla":1i4wcf6e said:
Get over it, Kirk sucks IMHO. The fact that he is wealthy or has sig gear does nothing to prove that he has talent

What he does is by its very nature, open to critique. Not liking what he does doesnt make anyone butthurt or jealous, that very notion is completely and utterly absurd..

This x10000000000.

Kirk sucks. FULL STOP.

This
 
Gainzilla":3jslfs4c said:
Steinmetzify":3jslfs4c said:
That's the part that bothers me.....the butthurt and the jealousy part of it.
Get over it, Kirk sucks IMHO. The fact that he is wealthy or has sig gear does nothing to prove that he has talent

What he does is by its very nature, open to critique. Not liking what he does doesnt make anyone butthurt or jealous, that very notion is completely and utterly absurd..

Goddammit Kage. The one time I try to be diplomatic in my initial response and you come and hit the fucking nail on the head.

My name is Dave and I too, believe Kirk Hammet's playing sucks cock 'n balls. Fuck it. He does. Yes, he's rich. What the fuck does that have to do with the fact that I had better vibrato when I was 13 then he does now. Seems like a nice guy though. :lol: :LOL: :D

PS,

IMO, the "butt-hurt" seems to come primarily from the Metallica fan-bois.

Dave-crest out!
 
compared to his peers of that era, he's pretty bad. Didn't Metallica once release an album with no guitar solos?

Alex Skolnik
Marty Friedman
Gary Holt
Lee Altus
Dan Spitz (maybe a tie?)
Dave Mustaine
Chuck Schuldiner
Chris Oliva
yeah, the list goes on.
 
Knockout":2of06tox said:
I think he is better than anyone on this forum, or TGP, Or JCF, or HC or...
Stick around a while, and you will see this is not true. There are many players here that have a much greater command of their instrument imho.
 
I could type out a whole lot of why he sucks, but let's just say comparatively speaking...he sucks. He consistently sucks. He just can't play consistently. James and Lars write and control everything. If Kirk could play in tune live he would be ok, but not even make it as a typical sideman. Pete Thorn is a zillion times the guitarist Kirk is.
 
Opinions, yep...everyones got one, everyones entitled to voice it. I think that the reason that so many threads such as this one take a negative turn is the terminology used. Consider this: why do a lot of people find being told something they like "sucks" offensive? Why? Because it can be taken as the other person saying, not only do I NOT like it, but YOU are a fucking idiot for liking it; and nothing jams that fact in your face better than telling you that the object of your liking performs fellatio on donkey dongs. This usually triggers the inevitable, oh yeah? well your mom sucks type response....and the fun just ensues from there creating repeating debates that are like bowling balls.........................pointless.
 
Kirk was one of the nicest guys I've ever had the opportunity to meet. (James was cool too...Lars was more aloof and Robert was super cool)

Kirk, I feel, put out some great stuff in the early days...then I feel like he hit a wall and has become almost a parody of himself (much like new Metallica)
Kinda hard to stay motivated and keep that anger/angst when you're worth $200 million

Kirk's made more money playing guitar than all the forumites combined but I stopped playing a wah pedal because of Kirk.

Old Metallica was great...New Metallica (like playing with Lou Reed) sucks

sub
 
Meh. Some of the early Metallica stuff really peaked my interest and made me want to play guitar more and better. I don't really follow Metallica but liked his work early on. Have seen some questionable performances as of late so no question he may be just getting older and sloppier. But I am far from saying anyone of his accOmplishment sucks. Heck 90 percent of the guys in this forum play much Bette then me ;)
 
Subclavian":2prqrbbe said:
Kirk was one of the nicest guys I've ever had the opportunity to meet. (James was cool too...Lars was more aloof and Robert was super cool)

Kirk, I feel, put out some great stuff in the early days...then I feel like he hit a wall and has become almost a parody of himself (much like new Metallica)
Kinda hard to stay motivated and keep that anger/angst when you're worth $200 million

Kirk's made more money playing guitar than all the forumites combined but I stopped playing a wah pedal because of Kirk.

Old Metallica was great...New Metallica (like playing with Lou Reed) sucks

sub

I must ask, what does being nice and having money have to do with your ability to play guitar? Reb Beach didn't say that Kirk was a poor douchebag, he said he was a shitty guitar player. Many of us agree that he is a rich rock star, that for all we know is a very nice guy. That is not being debated. Our opinions are about his playing. I have meet quite a few very nice, super talented musicians, of all different levels of fame and success. Of the guitar players, I would put most above Kirk. I do, however, respect what he has accomplished in his musical career, but I am not amazed at his talent comparatively speaking.
 
Knockout":3n69yuvr said:
I think he is better than anyone on this forum, or TGP, Or JCF, or HC or...

You could think it. But you'd be so, so, so very wrong.
 
Kirk is a worse guitar player than a lot of other guys. I guess that's a fact.
However i can't recall reading or seeing Kirk talking about how good he is or how bad some other guy is. So why do other people have this urge to say how bad he is?
 
Steinmetzify":3sfzsah1 said:
I really don't get all the hate for this guy.......are people really that mad at him?

The average music buying public(that aren't guitar players)don't even know what a vibrato is, let alone if it's off pitch.

They don't know what a wah pedal is, let alone if it's overused or not.

Someone said in another post that it comes off as jealousy, and that's all I can see.......this board is full of a nice mix of guys that play classic rock, metal, nu-metal, classical, and pretty much every other kind of guitar based music out there.

But what I see most as far as hater threads and off the cuff comments go is hating on Kirk.

His vibrato might not be the best. He might overuse his wah(HIS wah, you know......the one with his fucking NAME on it, that sells all over the country and the world? Yeah, that wah).

So fuckin what? Do all the haters play at their absolute BEST everytime they pick up a guitar? Really, do you? Is he not allowed to have an off night, and off month, or even an off year? He's been doing this for 30 YEARS, man......he's been doing this longer than some of the guys on this board have been ALIVE, and he's written some of the best music in his genre.

Can ANY of you haters say the same? Did any of you write the solo for Sanitarium? The rhythm for Disposable Heroes? The clean passages for Fade to Black? Have ANY of you written what was arguably the 3 or 4 most influential albums in metal and gotten them certified platinum without ANY radio play or video rotation?

Or....you know....are you just playing in your mom's basement or at a local club for 53 people who are so drunk and desperate for a night out that you could pretty much play anything and they'd cheer you because after paying the $4 cover to see your 'band', you actually think they've showed out to see you, and your super tight vibrato and your controlled as hell wah pedal? :no: :no: :no:

What if every single time you posted a vid here of your playing all anyone ever said was that you overused your EMGs, or that your vibrato blows......every single time?

Are you all so bitter and angry about the music career or lack thereof that you have, that the only outlet that you have is to start a hater thread about a fellow musician?

Take it for what it's worth......I think constructive criticism is all good......but just bashing something over and over for no other reason than you don't like it or are jealous of it is just lame in the highest sense of the word.

And that's what all the bashing around here is. Lame.

Music is supposed to be, above all.....fun. I think maybe some people here have forgotten that.

Rant over, bash on.
Kirk.... Is that you?
 
Back
Top