preamp gut elegance

  • Thread starter Thread starter guitarslinger
  • Start date Start date
:thumbsdown: Some of these preamps are using single sided PCBs and mounting large components like tubes on them. Not a good practice in my experience for long term reliability.
 
blackba":3vj5jias said:
:thumbsdown: Some of these preamps are using single sided PCBs and mounting large components like tubes on them. Not a good practice in my experience for long term reliability.

Dude, seriously?

In your experience, what amps and preamps have had problems because of this apparently,inherently shitty construction technique?

The PCB's on uber-expensive preamps are almost unbendable. like 3/16" thick. I can't IMAGINE anything, aside from a hammer causing damage between a socket and a durable PCB.

Steve Fryette would throw a fit if he were here. :cry:
 
Olaf, I thik it's about time to reveal finest german 'kraut' work :)

Larry - Dino 3033 three channel Preamp

dino_pre_3.jpg

dino_3033_guts.jpg


Larry - Jon Schaffer Signature Preamp

larry_jonschaffer_sigpreamp.jpg

1064p.jpg


But I still love my X99 the most .... :inlove:

SoldanoX99.jpg
 
The pad, barrel is through-hole double sided for the components. That :rock:

guitarslinger":t7javbo8 said:
blackba":t7javbo8 said:
:thumbsdown: Some of these preamps are using single sided PCBs and mounting large components like tubes on them. Not a good practice in my experience for long term reliability.

Dude, seriously?

In your experience, what amps and preamps have had problems because of this apparently,inherently shitty construction technique?

The PCB's on uber-expensive preamps are almost unbendable. like 3/16" thick. I can't IMAGINE anything, aside from a hammer causing damage between a socket and a durable PCB.

Steve Fryette would throw a fit if he were here. :cry:
 
Piero the Guitarero":3dugyglj said:
Olaf, I think it's about time to reveal finest german 'kraut' work :)
No clips --> no comment, Piero.

For me: X88R and CAE.
X88R = best crunch sound ever, CAE = awesome for everything
 
guitarslinger":tzt7g32p said:
blackba":tzt7g32p said:
:thumbsdown: Some of these preamps are using single sided PCBs and mounting large components like tubes on them. Not a good practice in my experience for long term reliability.

Dude, seriously?

In your experience, what amps and preamps have had problems because of this apparently,inherently shitty construction technique?

The PCB's on uber-expensive preamps are almost unbendable. like 3/16" thick. I can't IMAGINE anything, aside from a hammer causing damage between a socket and a durable PCB.

Steve Fryette would throw a fit if he were here. :cry:

VHT (now Fryette Amplication) uses double sided FR4 PCBs, which are good. I am only talking about single sided PCBs. My experience is with consumer electronics, not amps. However we had a board that was single sided CEM1 material and we had trouble with our larger components lifting solder pads after about 1-2 years. When we changed to double sided FR4 we stopped seeing these issues. This is due to the double sided FR4 PCB having a plated through hole and pads on both sides of the board, not just one. Upon closer inspection I only see one preamp that it is clear has a single sided PCB and its a single sided FR4, its the sound clinic climax. The rest are either double sided FR4 (green) which is what we use mostly. Or a double sided chem board, which looks like the PCBs we use on our early prototypes.

My Marshall 2553 silver jubilee has a single sided PCB, but it doesn't have large components on it and it has been fine. I am just pointing out a potential issue and not trying to stir up crap.
 
X88R
 

Attachments

  • More Real X88R Internals.jpg
    More Real X88R Internals.jpg
    52.5 KB · Views: 8,603
that was wierd, i liked what i was looking at but, i have no idea what i'm looking at! :lol: :LOL:
 
blackba":26iyikm8 said:
guitarslinger":26iyikm8 said:
blackba":26iyikm8 said:
:thumbsdown: Some of these preamps are using single sided PCBs and mounting large components like tubes on them. Not a good practice in my experience for long term reliability.

Dude, seriously?

In your experience, what amps and preamps have had problems because of this apparently,inherently shitty construction technique?

The PCB's on uber-expensive preamps are almost unbendable. like 3/16" thick. I can't IMAGINE anything, aside from a hammer causing damage between a socket and a durable PCB.

Steve Fryette would throw a fit if he were here. :cry:

VHT (now Fryette Amplication) uses double sided FR4 PCBs, which are good. I am only talking about single sided PCBs. My experience is with consumer electronics, not amps. However we had a board that was single sided CEM1 material and we had trouble with our larger components lifting solder pads after about 1-2 years. When we changed to double sided FR4 we stopped seeing these issues. This is due to the double sided FR4 PCB having a plated through hole and pads on both sides of the board, not just one. Upon closer inspection I only see one preamp that it is clear has a single sided PCB and its a single sided FR4, its the sound clinic climax. The rest are either double sided FR4 (green) which is what we use mostly. Or a double sided chem board, which looks like the PCBs we use on our early prototypes.

My Marshall 2553 silver jubilee has a single sided PCB, but it doesn't have large components on it and it has been fine. I am just pointing out a potential issue and not trying to stir up crap.

Thanks for the explanation. I thought you were trying to start shit :lol: :LOL: I thought you were one of those, "OMGZ, the sockets must be chassis mounted, or the amp sucks!" :cry:
 
Duke of Metal":2r7akurf said:
Thats awsome. When was that designed? :rock:
Just 10 days ago, on Tue 13-th the #001 went into the hands of Jon Schaffer, as he's been in Vienna/Austria on tour w/ Iced Earth. I still had to buy winter tyres, to drive the 500km there, because on this day a huge snow chaos broke in over Bavaria :aww: Currently I'm working on the #002 for myself. The idea & planning already has started in summer 2008, but most of the design I've first done during Dec. 2008 & Jan. 2009

Inearthed":2r7akurf said:
And how much for the preamp? Looks awesome.
Thanks! The final retail price still isn't calculated, but presumably will be about 2,200 EUR w/ current produced tubes (TungSol Reissue), or about 2,450 EUR w/ all NOS Tungsram ECC83 from the 70'

Btw: The 2 rack space 4-channel preamp seen some posts above is a design from 1993/94, when I've still built on solder strips - but it maybe will be coming soon again in an upgraded & reworked design. Still in my thoughts is a reborn of my 100W mono power amp from 1993 :)
Let's see, what the future shows and whether I can find some helping and skilled hands, to push my waiting time back below the 12 months line.

Still some pixs, which are my provisionally web pixs and will show up on my web site soon.

Larry
 

Attachments

  • 1074p.jpg
    1074p.jpg
    113.8 KB · Views: 8,426
  • 1073p.jpg
    1073p.jpg
    111.7 KB · Views: 8,431
  • 1066p.jpg
    1066p.jpg
    219.9 KB · Views: 8,477
  • 1064p.jpg
    1064p.jpg
    147.1 KB · Views: 8,441
  • 1061p.jpg
    1061p.jpg
    167.5 KB · Views: 8,438
  • 1086p.jpg
    1086p.jpg
    99.8 KB · Views: 8,425
novosibir":3ej64fkb said:
Duke of Metal":3ej64fkb said:
Thats awsome. When was that designed? :rock:
Just 10 days ago, on Tue 13-th the #001 went into the hands of Jon Schaffer, as he's been in Vienna/Austria on tour w/ Iced Earth. I still had to buy winter tyres, to drive the 500km there, because on this day a huge snow chaos broke in over Bavaria :aww: Currently I'm working on the #002 for myself. The idea & planning already has started in summer 2008, but most of the design I've first done during Dec. 2008 & Jan. 2009

Inearthed":3ej64fkb said:
And how much for the preamp? Looks awesome.
Thanks! The final retail price still isn't calculated, but presumably will be about 2,200 EUR w/ current produced tubes (TungSol Reissue), or about 2,450 EUR w/ all NOS Tungsram ECC83 from the 70'

Btw: The 2 rack space 4-channel preamp seen some posts above is a design from 1993/94, when I've still built on solder strips - but it maybe will be coming soon again in an upgraded & reworked design. Still in my thoughts is a reborn of my 100W mono power amp from 1993 :)
Let's see, what the future shows and whether I can find some helping and skilled hands, to push my waiting time back below the 12 months line.

Still some pixs, which are my provisionally web pixs and will show up on my web site soon.

Larry
Holy sh*t! its Larry. The man behind John Schaffer's massive sound. :rock: :rock:

very nice design on the preamps Larry. Look very nice. Look forward to trying one out one day.

say.. what preamp and power tubes do you use in your amps? Would you possibly know what tubes John Schaffer uses in his Larry amps?


Cheers
 
Back
Top