messenger
Well-known member
paulyc":2vttgadb said:
I think the 4 without Axl would have been good with just Izzy and Duff singing. I liked all the songs that those two sang.
I think the 4 without Axl would have been good with just Izzy and Duff singing. I liked all the songs that those two sang.
NaturalBornBoy
Well-known member
messenger":18lyj3mm said:
What songs on the 4, main GnR albums did Duff sing lead vocals??
nevusofota
Well-known member
Can Axle still sing?
NaturalBornBoy
Well-known member
nevusofota":2ooi71ja said:
Exactly this.
He can't sing the classic GnR songs anymore. I mean, he tried to with the circus freakshow that he called GnR but I stress the word 'tried'.
I would much rather Slash, Steven, Izzy and Duff reform with Myles Kennedy and fucking play the shit outta the GnR classics!
messenger
Well-known member
NaturalBornBoy":2cpvh0in said:
So Fine, Can't Put Your Arms Around a Memory, New Rose, and Attitude.
NaturalBornBoy
Well-known member
messenger":24iufck6 said:
Ok I don't consider 'The Spaghetti Incident' one of the main GnR albums cos' it was only covers so it's only 'So Fine' then.
But even on 'So Fine' it wasn't just him on lead vox. It was him and Axl.
messenger
Well-known member
Ya
JimmyBlind
Active member
G'n'R were a steaming pile of festering turds.
messenger
Well-known member
JimmyBlind":11zxs9o0 said:
Lol. Tell us how u really feel
P
paulyc
Well-known member
The original 4 with Myles out front would only really work as a touring entity I think, they COULD record an album, and it would probably be a great one, but Myles doesn't write lyrics like Ax-hole about "classic" GNR themes...
JimmyBlind
Active member
messenger":2smy9vt4 said:
Up the Irons!
mooncobra
Well-known member
they should just play Appetite. All the way through.
squank
Active member
The magic is long gone with GnR. A complete reunion with the entire group still would not produce the magic they had in the late 80s early 90s, imo.
thegame
Well-known member
Speaking terms sure...I don't think Axl is on singing terms with anyone these days.
messenger
Well-known member
squank":2dcossra said:
No one can say that. Wouldn't know if there was any "magic" left unless they all got in a room together and started playing.
T
Tone Zone
Banned
New member
thegame":8v5da0hh said:
Badronald
New member
messenger":3kkis3of said:
Sure you can. They caught lightning in a bottle once. It'll never happen again.
They could be good, but they'll never reproduce that magic.
messenger
Well-known member
Badronald":35h86ht6 said:messenger":35h86ht6 said:
Sure you can. They caught lightning in a bottle once. It'll never happen again.
They could be good, but they'll never reproduce that magic.
Why not? I mean it's doubtful but how do u say "it'll never happen again". Even the Illusion albums weren't recorded as a band and a lot of the songs were written prior to AFD bring recorded. So who's to say what would happen if they actually spent time in a room writing.
GOHOINC
Well-known member
Because Axl cant sing anymore. That's how anyone could say it will never happen again. They may get back together and write the best song or album anyone has ever written. The music may be unbelievable but with him singing it will sound like shit. His voice is gonzo...
messenger
Well-known member
Well his singing live has never been good. Listen to the Tokyo Show. So I don't think that's much of an indicator 
