Synergy Syn20 IR of Fryette GPDI/IR? Help me decide

[VH4paul]

Hi guys,
I'm looking for an analog/hybrid system for studio use, and I'm torn between the Synergy SYN-20IR and the Fryette GPDI/IR.
My main concern is the tone and feel when using direct-out tones with IRs (i.e., not going into a real mic'd-up cab) but I can't find any A/B comparisons of their direct tones. From what I understand, the SYN-20IR has an emulated power amp section, while the GPDI/IR features a proper 1W power amp with an integrated reactive load which, on paper, should provide a more realistic experience.
I just don't know how much of a difference it makes in real-life applications, and whether it's enough to justify giving up the Synergy's versatility. I mostly lean toward Fryette modules anyway, but the SYN-20IR would also let me add more flavors.
Has anyone tried both who could help me decide?
Thanks a lot!

 

[Jccobb2]

I’d get the synergy. Some of the new modules have a 0 watt power amp phase inverter thing that’s supposed to help with feel.

Main reason though is the variety. That system lets you play whatever amp you want easily.

 

[ewill52]

Synergy for me just because of the variety and it sounds great!

 

[gibsonash]

This !

 

[HellraiserJohnny]

I use the IR (XLR Out) from my Syn 2 with Tdlx and Freyette PB directly to the studio via snake from the tracking room. It sounds killer to me . . . .

Sample: Track - The Cost