I don't know how you got our amp to sound good on the first try. I keep trying to record with my SM57 and it always sounds like crap when I try. It's frustrating.
A little luck probably. I used the bottom speaker, someone told me to try the top next time and I will.
Recording is frustrating and ive been doing it off and on for ages, only with amp Sims until now.
I'm absolutely not the person to take Recording advice from but out of all of the things I've read and tried and learned here are the basics that I wholeheartedly agree with.
* The performance is the absolute most important thing.
If it isn't tight, redo it. Absolutely have to nail the take. I didnt nail shit here. It was good enough for me on a sick day but wouldnt release this.
Get it sounding good at the source. Then whoever mixes it can make it sound great.
* EQ!!! And use High pass/Low pass filters.
I guess this could be up for debate and opinion but I think its widely accepted that guitar frequencies should not go below or above a certain area and I always pass the eq. This Recording was around 90hz and 12,000hz I believe.
* Bass
I personally feel the bass guitar is more important than a lot of people would think. A great bass tone makes your guitars sound awesomer.
* Volumes
are pretty important to me, have to hear everything clearly. Dont want too much crash or too little kick, etc etc.
Again, im a hack but these are the basic fundamentals that I believe