Which amp is the right one for me?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Alfi27
  • Start date Start date
A

Alfi27

New member
Hi guys. My first post in here, but I've been a member of other forums since 2009. Just a quick question before we start: do I have to have x number of posts before I can post in the classifieds?

So, to the case: I have been through a shitload of amps, not to mentions guitars, never quite finding what I want. Well, that is not exactly true, my 2553 Jubilee gave me my first tonegasm ever. Then I found out that my late Kemper did everything I wanted and more, which was true. However, I have always been a fan of the less is more concept and I figured that the Kemper was way too much for me. Besides, I didn't find it very rock n' roll plugging into a computer looking like a 70's NASA toaster, haha! Don't get me wrong, great unit for those advanced players who change presets for every song, but not for me. I eventually sold the Kemper, and bought a Friedman Runt 50. Also a great amp, but it died after two months (brand new). Shipped it back to the UK where I bought it from (I live in Norway) because I had already paid over 100$ for getting the bias adjusted, and I didn't want to get it fixed locally for even more money that no one would take responsibility for (it is, after all, an expensive amp). I do now regret that I didn't bit the bullet and did it, because it arrived completely smashed by the carrier. The chassis is loose, transformers are probably damaged, but no one can (or want to) find out exactly.

After getting over the loss of my Runt, I found a used Suhr SL67 at a good price (also in the UK...). I got it, and I still have it. Works perfectly, sounds great, BUT. It is very very vintage sounding, with a looser bottom end than I want. It does take pedals well, but it doesn't tighten up quite as I want it to. If I was Eddie or Page or whoever it would have been a perfect amp, but I play and like more modern rock (as well as the old classics of course). It is also extremely loud, which I did expect it to be but I guess I hoped the master volume would work better than it does. Right now the only way I can get a satisfactory distorted tone without ear plugs is running my Friedman BE OD through the SL67 on a clean setting. I think that's why the Jubilee sounded so great to me, because it sounded like the perfect synergy of vintage and modern and with the gain at 12 o clock it had the perfect amount of gain for about any heavier rock tone, with AC/DC tones slightly lower in the gain range.

Ever since my early teenage years, when I first picked up a shitty Fernandes strat copy, my idol was Slash and especially his playing and tone on Appetite for Destruction. Oddly enough I have only owned one signature amp of his, the SL-5, which sounded good but not excessively Slashy. Unrelated, 5 watt is a very annoying and just plain odd wattage because it is too loud to crank at home, and too quiet for band use. I did consider the AFD100 multiple times, but eventually forgot about it because of reported reliability issues.

Another tonal favourite of mine, and in later years also stylistic influence is Billie Joe on Dookie. That raw, tight, fat but still aggressive wall of sound is just so awesome! Of course it is double tracked and whatnot, but that's at least a reference.

That's for the slightly more modern tones, but I also love AC/DCs tone and Van Halen's VHI tone (which I pretty much nail with the SL67 and 4x12 EVH cab) and more clean slightly broken up tones and at the opposite end of the spectrum; Metallica. Not their exact scooped tone, but an amp/tone that can handle that style.

I'm starting to think that all of this is not obtainable with one amp, but there will obviously be some compromises and I'm going for the ballpark more than spot on, as long as the core tone is great. It should be possible to find amps that can do it, but I have other criteria:

- Big tone, small size; preferably nothing bigger than the SL67 but it would be great with something really small like the Splawn Super Sport (mini), Marshall 2525H, Bogner Atma etc.

- Tight and articulate bottom end, very important.

- Wattage is not that important, I would rather have too much than too little as long as it's not dependent on power amp distortion like the SL67.

- It has to be versatile, but not too many bells and whistles. I love the concept of the Fargen Olde 800s with three different modes/decades on the same (only) channel. At least nothing more fancy than the Atma, and if the amp has midi switching that's a sign that it's too complicated for me :lol: :LOL:

- It has to cope with a loud drummer, and I don't mind a little breakup on my clean tones at those volumes.

- It has to have a clean tone, either available on the same channel as the overdrive like the SL67 or a dedicated clean channel.

What I know would have been perfect for me is the Wizard MC25, as I have tried two Modern Classics (100w though) and they sounded so freakin' glorious. Great high gain tones that chug like a champ, but also great AC/DC type tones (what would you expect from AC/DC's guitar tech, haha), but they're so damn expensive new and very hard to find used. If someone owns one and want to exchange it for my SL67, don't be afraid to send me a PM!

I should also mention that I owned the Friedman Pink Taco, and did not like it at all... Congested sounding amp, with a very strange frequency curve. Really dry sounding even with max gain (which is a lot), sounded 10x better with the BE OD directly to the fx loop return.

A list of amps that I consider, some harder to find than others:
Marshall Jubilee (2553, 2525, 2555), Splawn Super Sport, Jet City JCA20H Friedman modded, Marshall/Ceriatone 2204/1987 Friedman modded, Bogner Atma, Fargen Olde 800 MKII and probably some I forgot that I'll update later!

Thanks a lot in advance!

- Alf
 
I'm a big fan of the Suhr SL amps, however you're right, they certainly sit on the "vintage" end of the spectrum.

Have you considered a 5150 50watt head? I've had one for a few years now and there is something special about the blue channel. Tight and percussive in a modern kind of way yet juicy and full sounding. It's an easy amp to overlook in the company of boutique monsters but give it a shot!

Of course if money was no object, I'd go and buy a Bogner 101b. Simply my favourite amp of all time. Totally versatile and utterly crushing! Not exactly portable but oh so worth it!

Luke
 
I know what would fit you. A Wizard Modern Classic. Tight, immediate classic marshall tone. Very plexi like but can get pretty brutal. Metallica have used one for many years. Also THE ac-dc amp

EDIT: And now I see that you live in Norway. I have one that I can part with.
 
eh.. sounds to me like you want a simple multi channel amp.

first not super expensive idea i got was Egnater Tourmaster, Not sure about the availability in the UK but capable of the range of tones you are looking for with some egnater flair.

Single/dual channel wise with switching options. Wizard MTL it can do more classic stuff as well as modern, Fortin Bones (not sure if Mike is taking orders on these right now)

maybe something Diezel has?

seems like you are trying to cover alot of ground with one amp.
 
Thanks a lot guys!

Leftycatton: I actually own an EVH 5150III LBX as well as the Suhr, and it's a great little amp! Best lunchbox amp I've ever played, blowing the Pink Taco, at more than three times the price here in Norway, out of the water! However, it does not have the right Marshall roar and raw mid range, too smooth and compressed. Not that great for lower gain tones either, but for medium to super high gain it just rips!

Peterc52: Sent you an email, man! Hope we can work something out.

eternal_idol: a multi channel amp is definitely not what I want, I hate space ship looking amps like the ENGL Invader, Marshall JVM410H etc that you have to set up a weekend course for that poor bastard who wants to borrow it for his Saturday night gig next weekend. :D

If the Suhr could have been boosted into a great metal tone it would have been almost there, and an amp with a slightly more modern tone and tighter bottom end that take pedals well and/or have built in boost(s) like the Wizard MC for pushing it over the top is exactly what I want. Preferably not more than two, and definitely not more than three channels.
EDIT: I'm a dumbass, multi = more than one, of course! Haha, oh well. At least we got that cleared out! :D Then you are completely right, a multi channel amp is what I want.
 
Im gonna differ here some, I think the SL67 can be plenty tight BUT that EVH 4x12 with the EVH/Heritage G12M's are the issue. I have an SL67 and with V30's, or any heavy magnet speaker it is tight and a good OD like your BE or the Suhr Eclipse or XTS Atomic will get you there gain wise.

Some of the extra low-end that can get a little muddy can be solved by removing 1 capacitor on the board if you know what your doing inside a tube amp.

Also tubes make a big difference, especially if they are old as it seems they maybe since you bought the amp used. So don't throw in the towel just yet on the Suhr...
 
mixn4him":rlcfqe5s said:
Im gonna differ here some, I think the SL67 can be plenty tight BUT that EVH 4x12 with the EVH/Heritage G12M's are the issue. I have an SL67 and with V30's, or any heavy magnet speaker it is tight and a good OD like your BE or the Suhr Eclipse or XTS Atomic will get you there gain wise.

Some of the extra low-end that can get a little muddy can be solved by removing 1 capacitor on the board if you know what your doing inside a tube amp.

Also tubes make a big difference, especially if they are old as it seems they maybe since you bought the amp used. So don't throw in the towel just yet on the Suhr...
Thanks for that, and I think you might be right. I will get new speakers tomorrow, a quad of Wizard Rock 20 made by Eminence exclusive for Wizard amps, so we will see how it works out. How does your SL67 behave with the master volume? Even when I run mine with a 1x12 with a Creamback 75H it is really loose in the low end with the master at 12 o clock, but when I turn it up more it tightens up nicely. That's one of the things I don't like, because that means that I will be totally dependent on my pedals for a gig where I can't turn it that much up.
 
Alfi27":1ha9wq42 said:
mixn4him":1ha9wq42 said:
Im gonna differ here some, I think the SL67 can be plenty tight BUT that EVH 4x12 with the EVH/Heritage G12M's are the issue. I have an SL67 and with V30's, or any heavy magnet speaker it is tight and a good OD like your BE or the Suhr Eclipse or XTS Atomic will get you there gain wise.

Some of the extra low-end that can get a little muddy can be solved by removing 1 capacitor on the board if you know what your doing inside a tube amp.

Also tubes make a big difference, especially if they are old as it seems they maybe since you bought the amp used. So don't throw in the towel just yet on the Suhr...
Thanks for that, and I think you might be right. I will get new speakers tomorrow, a quad of Wizard Rock 20 made by Eminence exclusive for Wizard amps, so we will see how it works out. How does your SL67 behave with the master volume? Even when I run mine with a 1x12 with a Creamback 75H it is really loose in the low end with the master at 12 o clock, but when I turn it up more it tightens up nicely. That's one of the things I don't like, because that means that I will be totally dependent on my pedals for a gig where I can't turn it that much up.

The master works great very even sounding, can get a little soft if the gain is up too much but running it clean or edge of breakup/crunch its tight. I'm using Creambacks in a 2x12 which can be a little soft in the bass but my 4x12 has the vented T75 Celestions and that cab is tight no matter how I set the amp.

The VH4 pedal would be another pedal to consider...
 
mixn4him":3e7373l2 said:
Alfi27":3e7373l2 said:
mixn4him":3e7373l2 said:
Im gonna differ here some, I think the SL67 can be plenty tight BUT that EVH 4x12 with the EVH/Heritage G12M's are the issue. I have an SL67 and with V30's, or any heavy magnet speaker it is tight and a good OD like your BE or the Suhr Eclipse or XTS Atomic will get you there gain wise.

Some of the extra low-end that can get a little muddy can be solved by removing 1 capacitor on the board if you know what your doing inside a tube amp.

Also tubes make a big difference, especially if they are old as it seems they maybe since you bought the amp used. So don't throw in the towel just yet on the Suhr...
Thanks for that, and I think you might be right. I will get new speakers tomorrow, a quad of Wizard Rock 20 made by Eminence exclusive for Wizard amps, so we will see how it works out. How does your SL67 behave with the master volume? Even when I run mine with a 1x12 with a Creamback 75H it is really loose in the low end with the master at 12 o clock, but when I turn it up more it tightens up nicely. That's one of the things I don't like, because that means that I will be totally dependent on my pedals for a gig where I can't turn it that much up.

The master works great very even sounding, can get a little soft if the gain is up too much but running it clean or edge of breakup/crunch its tight. I'm using Creambacks in a 2x12 which can be a little soft in the bass but my 4x12 has the vented T75 Celestions and that cab is tight no matter how I set the amp.

The VH4 pedal would be another pedal to consider...

Yes I agree, it works great with the master at 12 o'clock if the gain is at about 1 o'clock or lower, but with gain maxed out it's very saggy and soft in the bass. Great for leads, but for palm muting it's close to useless and I don't feel like it tightens up sufficiently with a boost either. I guess I was too blinded by Pete Thorn's magnificent demo of this amp to actually think through how the amp would do in an actual gig or practice setting. In the real world you can't run a Plexi, 50 or 100 watt, at full volume and unless you carry an attenuator; the tone will be degraded when lowering the volume. Besides, I will be attending to a (very expensive) music school in the UK from September and really need all the money I can get. I think I'll look around for a more reasonably priced amp like a DSL50, or maybe a Jubilee if I find a cheap one. If you have any other suggestions that would be great, in the 1000$ range or lower :)
 
Back
Top