Basically what they're trying to do is blame carpet damage on me that was there when I moved in, and they knew it was there because the property manager didn't deny it in an email when I told him they knew it was there; it's a big rust like spot and the shampooers would have noted it didn't come out last time they were cleaned. Anywho, I'm going to ask them for receipts for legal purposes of when the carpet was replaced last, but likely at least 11 years ago, which basic stains and spots are common wear and tear items. Since the carpet is likely 11 years old or more, they don't have as much of a leg to stand on. Also, rather than replacing it with carpet, like they're trying to steal my deposit for, they replaced it with faux hardwood. So basically they're trying to steal my deposit for upgrades.