My SW rep (that I didn't choose and had no voice about it) wanted to talk to me about how I was liking my "gear."
I ordered 5 Gravity picks. And proceeded to tell him how thrilled I was with them.
He's never called me since.....
The Holcomb models have a 20" radius. Though I have older core models as well, I was surprised that the Holcomb is really easy and comfortable to play.
You sound like me with my LP. Finnicky, fickle, maddening, awesome beast that needed the right pickups. Ended up getting a BK Nailbomb set (used, here on this site, actually) and it was both a surprise and a pleasure to realize I found the set I will never replace. That was 10+ years ago.
Your facility in buying and selling guitars so often (like today!) is either a skill or a curse that I do not have. Not sure I could do what you're doing, but you be you, you.
I can speak from personal experience. My keeper Explorer tried out Afwayus, Aldrich(es?), BKP Nailbombs, even Gibson 57/57+, and still with all those awesome pickups, it wasn't right. Mrs. I bought this for my b-day, so I mean it's mine for life, so I may as well figure out what works...
One on TGP: https://www.thegearpage.net/board/index.php?threads/prs-2012-stripped-58-navy-blue.2243733/
(Not mine, but I'm a sucker for the moons vs. the birds, so it caught my eye.)
I've bought many online without playing first. I guess I found what tonewoods, electronics, bridges, fingerboard radii and other such nerdy shit works for me, so I decide to purchase based on the specs of the guitar.
I recently bought (of all things) a Harley Benton Agufish from Thomann in...
I have a hard time with the right adjectives, but yeah, after writing a paragraph, I realized what you wrote above me is pretty accurate. So I'll spare you and others all the extra words.
My Hyperion with the Ferals is pretty much my go-to rhythm guitar for heavier riffs.
They're in my Hyperion, and one of the only guitars I've left as stock (I'm a serial pickup-swapper by trade). They work well with high gain, and are perfect for this guitar. I've given thought to buy a set for a non-Balaguer guitar, until I look in my parts drawer and see all the other unused...
I have 2 BG Hellabuckers, one black and one zebra. Black is 50mm, zebra is 53mm.
I also have a Manlius Asphalt in black. 50mm.
All are short-legged. None have been direct mounted.
PM me if you want more info/pics.