I see what you are saying now that I have my PlexiRanger. I thought you were only using the boost side but you already had the Plexi side on correct? The button clicks where just engaging and disengaging the boost side? The gain was already there from the Plexi side.
This is the best premade pedal I've ever heard and I haven't even had a chance to spend much time with it. I still like my hand built Green Pony from BYOC a little better because it sounds a bit more raw and aggressive but the PlexiRanger is very close and definitely the most raw and aggressive pre-made pedal I've purchased. Plus it will probably give me more of that hot rod plexi tone once I get a chance to dial it in and work with it more. It is a cool pedal that I am looking forward to spending some time with. Glad I got it and thanks for recommending it Fret-Shredder. I'd been thinking about getting a Plexi but I don't think I need to now.