my first impression is this:
immediately it does not "feel" as gratifying and pure as it does plugging straight in to a very great tube amp, but i do see that you can easily reproduce the "sounds" of most any amp, so if you are willing to wade through tons of variables to get to the sound you're after, it's probably in there. so the velvety touch of valves loading and exploding, and the interaction of a pulsing 4x12 is missing at the moment. and when you try to reproduce it using compression, or cab thump, or bass controls, it's not the same. but it's way better playing through a power amp/speaker than it is with headphones. i need to try it with my bogner 4x12
there is also a thing in the highs i'm struggling with. with a real amp the zing of the metal in the string comes though clearly on a nice fendery clean tone and touch controls how bright or how dark you make it. i come from an acoustic background so i'm very picky about touch affecting tone in that regard. that part doesn't seem as delicate on the axe, although it is surprisingly sensitive to pick nuances on gainier patches. but higher gain sounds are always easier to achieve on any modeller. it's the clean and low gain tones i feel modellers earn their keep and the axe so far is great in this realm but i'm not totally satisfied yet.
my biggest complaint about the thing is:
i scoured all 300+ presets to find 10 i could start working on.
steve did mention i could download dry patches and start from there, which i will probably do, but not right of the bat until i know the unit better and feel comfortable storing and transferring data. i'm curious about the IR but that seems light years away from my ability and depth with the thing right now.
i'd suggest the factory starting with the first 10 presets being classic dry amps with knobs at noon, from fender twin clean, fender bassman dirty, vox ac 30 clean and dirty, marshall jtm 45 clean, marshall plexi dirty, mesa clean, mesa dirty, dumble clean, dumble dirty,
with drive box, cab, compression, reverb and delay in the chain but disabled, and all of these items set to ideal parameters ready to go if the user enables them in the chain.
then as you scroll up the preset numbers the sounds can become more boutique and fx laden. maybe the next 10 presets should be the top 10 user designed presets owners are downloading and liking (brown, U2, echoplex, tristereo, etc)
i love the sounds of the effects in this box. the best rack effect unit i have personally ever owned. and it's not a knock against my gforce because that thing is sick too, but it doesn't do lexicon verb like axe does, nor does it do eventide pitchshifting like the axe does, nor does it do a 2290 emulation as well as the axe does! pay attention tc!