HNGD x2 - Fender Stratocasters - American Ultra II HSS and Player II Modified HSS - Review

  • Thread starter Thread starter HowieJams
  • Start date Start date
HowieJams

HowieJams

Well-known member
Last year I got rid of all of my Fenders (Strats and Teles), PRS, and Ibanez guitars and cut down to only Gibsons, 4 Les Pauls and 1 SG.

Every time I buy Fenders I move on from them, I have never had a Fender that does it for me.

I love the sound of a Fender Strat neck pickup and the 2 and 4 positions, but I also need a Humbucker in the bridge.

The problem is, the humbucker with the middle pickup doesn't get that authentic quack I like, so a coil tap is necessary.

Also, my amps are high gain, so noiseless pickups are nice to have, but they don't always sound as good as regular single coils.

I bought the Player II Modified HSS first to see if I really want a Fender, it was around $1000 new.
I bought the Yellow with Rosewood fretboard.
It arrived from Sweetewater and after quite a few hours tweaking the action it plays great, except for a slight fretting out on the 17th fret on the E and B string, I think it is a slight high fret.

Sound from the Noiseless pickups is very autthentic Strat tines, nice snap, twang, and quack. I love the guitar.
It wowed me so much I decided to buy the American Ultra II HSS.
I went with the Solar Flare color with a Maple Fretboard, I considered the Ebony board, but Maple is more Strat like, if they would have offered Rosewood as an option I would have grabbed it.

It arrived and out of the box the playaility was very good, but I tweked the action and now it has amazing low action and plays great with no fretting out.
The Compound Radius neck is much thicker than the Player II 9.5" Radius Modern C, but it feels great.

Keep in mind I love the Player II Modified, but the Ultra II just feels like super high quality, the Player II feels great also, but there is a difference.

As for tone, this is where it gets tricky.
The Player II Modified HSS sounds like a Strat, the noiseless pickups are very responsive, but definitely low output like a regular single coil pickups.
Splitting the humbucker gets you a very convincing single coil sound.

I trulty love the sound of the Player II Modified.

The Ultra II HSS took me a little time, lowering the action helped get more Fender like tones out of it.
The Cleans are definitely more smooth and Hi Fi sounding than the Player II pickups, the are Strat like, but not as Strat like as the Player II Modified pickups.
With distortion the Ultra II pickups sound great, still not as Strat like as the Player II, but definitely sounds like a Strat and they sound great in their pown way, just not a Traditional Strat sound, a more Modern Strat sound.

I am going to keep both Strats, the American Ultra II HSS is the best built Strat I have ever owned and it plays better than any Fender I have ever owned.
The Player II Modified HSS is just so fun to play, it feels so light and easy to play. The Player II Modified feels like a nimble Sports car and the Ultra II HSS feels like a solid High end Sports car.

It took me a while to get used to the tone of the Ultra II HSS, but it definitely grew on me.

I have posted many videos of the Player II HSS Modified on YouTube, I will do some vids of the Ultra II HSS when I get a chance.

I was also considering a American Professional II HSS with a Rosewood Board, I bet that would have authentic Strat tones, but also with 60 cycle hum.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5736.JPG
    IMG_5736.JPG
    1.8 MB · Views: 49
  • IMG_5738.JPG
    IMG_5738.JPG
    2.1 MB · Views: 42
  • IMG_5739.JPG
    IMG_5739.JPG
    2.1 MB · Views: 41
Great review! You have a nice selection of guitars in your stable. Which amp to you gravitate towards with your strats?
 
Great review! You have a nice selection of guitars in your stable. Which amp to you gravitate towards with your strats?
Thanks!
Definitely my Soldanos, either my SLO-30 or Astro 20.
Here are 3 videos using my Strats, I haven't had a chance to play over a backing track with the Astro 20 and a Strat yet, but I have tons using my Les Pauls.





 
Over the past few years I have found how much I really like playing strats and teles. I have been wondering how those Ultra necks feel given their compound radius and "D" shaped carve that everyone says feels thicker than their modern C. What would you compare it to? I have almost bought one of those necks off ebay several times to try on one of my partscasters and always backed out just due to them being expensive and me being uncertain about that shape.
 
Thanks!
Definitely my Soldanos, either my SLO-30 or Astro 20.
Here are 3 videos using my Strats, I haven't had a chance to play over a backing track with the Astro 20 and a Strat yet, but I have tons using my Les Pauls.






Great playing! I have to say I liked the Ultra better, definitely more "modern" sounding as you identified. What are you using to record? Is this a mic'd cab or direct? Cheers!
 
Over the past few years I have found how much I really like playing strats and teles. I have been wondering how those Ultra necks feel given their compound radius and "D" shaped carve that everyone says feels thicker than their modern C. What would you compare it to? I have almost bought one of those necks off ebay several times to try on one of my partscasters and always backed out just due to them being expensive and me being uncertain about that shape.
I love the compound radius neck, being I am usually a Traditionalist and like 9.5" on my Fenders and 12" on my Gibsons, it was a pleasant surprise.
My Player II Modified has a 9.5" neck and the Ultra II has the Compound radius, I prefer the Compound radius, no fretting out in the upper registers so I can keep the action lower than the 9.5"
If you like a Modern C you will like the Compund radius.
 
Great playing! I have to say I liked the Ultra better, definitely more "modern" sounding as you identified. What are you using to record? Is this a mic'd cab or direct? Cheers!
Thanks!
I just use my Iphone 13 to record from about 3-5 feet away from the cabs.
I play at low volumes, around 80-85dB, so the Iphone works well.
If I played loud it would probably not do as well recording.
Both are great guitars, at first I preferred the sound of the Player II as it was more vintage sounding, but the Ultra II grew on me and is my favorite Strat I have ever owned. It is close enough to Vintage sounding for me.
 
Back
Top