What pedals were they? That's interesting.
I don't mean to say you're wrong. There are many pedals that sound great. But my point is I'd feel more like I'm playing a "pro" piece of gear if I plug a pedal into the FX loop than into the front end of the amp, personally. Like those Revv or AMT pedals. Those sound great into a nice poweramp.
Pedal in front of a clean channel, I immediately think two swituations: Either a dude in a cover band who has like a nice pro-level clean amp like a Bassman or something that needs to cover a lot of ground with sounds, but where a nice chunky distorted tone isn't his #1 prio, or someone running a clean practice amp that has a lousy distorted sound, and needs a more usable chunky sound. Could range from a Peavey Rage to maybe even a Blues Junior or something higher-end.
Maybe I'm just overgeneralizing or projecting. I just wished this Soldano pedal had a "preamp mode" where I could just run it into a nice tube poweramp and not feel like 12 year old me attemtping to play System of a Down riffs with a DS-1 into a Yamaha 10 watt amp, LOL.
Plug it into a mic preamp, and send the line out to a power amp.
I also think you're over analyzing this. Soldano makes a rackmount preamp already, and it costs big $$$$, especially if you pair it with their power amp.
This is for people who like you pointed out are either using this with a pedal platform amp, whether covers or originals, OR maybe people that maybe already have a two or more channel amp, but possibly want something to use as an alternate tone for blending. Or maybe they are looking to add a third different sounding channel in essence to a two channel amp.
While I don't doubt they could have tweaked this and made an awesome sounding rackmount SS preamp, they would essentially be punching themselves in the dick and possibly lose out on some of the higher dollar tube preamps they sell.
Also it might end up being significantly more expensive considering the size difference, possible circuit tweaks, more connections. The pedal format keeps it cheaper, and more easily integrated into the average guitarists rig.
Tbt even with two channels it would probably need to be no larger than 1/2 U, so maybe not so much on the cost of the enclosure, but you get my point?
And yeah, I know this is an old af post.
