I think it's a mistake to think that any one piece can be for everybody. And to tout it as such is stupidity...whether its the Axe-Fx, or a Strat, or a LCD TV or a g-spot-vibrator.....or a brand of beer.
It's also stupid to dismiss any gear for someone else's needs. Lord willing (or the Universe, or Fish-Hat, or Flying Spaghetti Monster), I'll never hit record with a POD again... but I've heard a zillion clips that flat out RULE using them...and I've made 2 cds with them myself.
In summary, everyone wants to seem smartest. And most opinions are useless. Need proof? Post a pic of a woman you think is hot...and await the bullshit.