First off I am a Charvel dealer and sell these new Charvels so you can take all this with a grain of salt. I've sold a ton of them to guys on Rig-Talk. I am also a long time Charvel San Dimas collector. I have owned or had my hands on anywhere from 80-100 of the original, real deal, "holy grail", San Dimas era Charvels. For some reason they even considered me enough of an expert to be interviewed for the Charvel book that came out several years ago.
Here's some guitars that have gone through my hands. Included in the pic is the black strat head that Rowan Robertson used to record Dio's "Lock Up The Wolves". The black/green/yellow hot rod flame in the front row belonged to George Lynch and he was pictured with it on the cover of the Rhino CD "Best of Dokken". The blood-splattered one in the middle row is THE infamous "Redrum" guitar that was very well known in Charvel circles.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that I know Charvels. I'm not the world's foremost Charvel expert, but I know them ok? I lived in LA in the 80's and I started hunting for the US ones in 1985 as soon as production went to Japan. I have played a ton of the Japanese Charvels. Some of them have been decent guitars.
These new production Charvels with a little set-up here, maybe a pickup swap there are killer guitars that I would defintely put up "Tone-wise" against any of the original San Dimas Charvels I have ever owned. I own two old ones and I own two new ones. I love the new ones once I have done a little massaging to them to make them my own. The same sort of things I did to all my original Charvels and one of the guys in this has done to his Japanese Charvel. I have NEVER found an off the rack guitar to be exactly what I like. I would never compare something off the rack to something I have played for years and years and made exactly what I want out of it. What I feel in these Charvels right off the rack is potential. Tons of potential. And yeah for about $1000 brand new I think a guitar having potential to be exactly what I want is just about the right price.