I have a Catalyst 100; I use it in 4CM + MIDI with my HX Effects. Sounds good for what it is, I'd use it live. Also have a small wireless rig based on the Mooer Prime P1, I like it too; sounds good but no feel, I'd use it live. I have a Boss SY-1000, I like it too, I'd use it live. The cost vs tube amps is good too.
None of these are better than my tube amps, more versatile, lighter, sound good, etc., sure.
FWIW, I used modeling for years starting with the original Vox ToneLab tabletop, to Fractal, to Boss, to Line 6, Zoom, etc. I get it, I like it, but still prefer tube amps, including my Marshall Origin 50, more.