I originally posted this in January of 2022, in another forum. To date, I've barealy used any of these picks mentioned below. I'm much more of a fingerstyle player - even on an electric.
===================
I've been a a huge fan of Dunlop Jazz III picks for many years; but as rarely as I use flat picks, these days, I can't say there's one pick that does it all.
Recently, I decided to experiment a little, to see if I can fall in love with a certain pick that does the trick for me.
Used to be the Jazz III. Maybe it still is?
I've grown more accustomed to playing most everything with my fingers; but sometimes a flat pick comes in handy.
I'm mostly a Dunlop fan (I've tried stainless, stone, etc....always come back to Dunlop - usually Ultex), when it comes to flat picks.
I cannot stand the sound or feel of thin picks, for my playing style. I admit, I once did did when I first started playing about forty years ago, because they were easier to use. But now I prefer the positive contact and meatier tone of a thicker pick; so I avoid the thinner ones like the plague.
The thicker picks also tend to sound similar to my fingernails (which I have to keep at just the right length, to get the right combination of flesh and nail, for the right sound out of my strings, when I'm playing fingerstyle - which is almost always. I'm lucky to have really strong, thick nails. Have never tried acrylics, and probably never will.
This way, when I switch over from fingerstyle to flat pick, there's no huge disparity between the sound/tone - very handy. Sound people appreciate this, and I don't have to use any tricks with my EQ pedals, either.
Recently picked up these. As rarely as I use a flat pick, these will probably last me ten years LOL.
Top left: Dunlop Tortex Medium/Heavy Variety Pack
Top Right: Dunlop Flow Ultex Variety Pack (ranging from
.73mm to 3.0mm) - probably won't even touch the .73mm ones.
Bottom Left: The old tried and true Dunlop Jazz III "Stiffo"
Bottom Right: Dunlop John Petrucci Custom Flow Ultex (2.0mm)