I will just say this last one thing. Because i am trying to tell you how to fix things that i see on your dials. If you have preamp gain maxed on amp and tubescreamer gain maxed on pedal, then you are going to get a dark flubby mess. When i seee that with treble higher than presence, that is why i say start with presence dimed.
Presence gives you gain, but the higher register, tighter gain. So the preamp gain is gojng to give you more bass as it gets higher, and the tone is going to be less tight.
The treble acts as high end, but makes it scratchy and you can hear it when you pick the strings.
The mids don't have to be high, but are a taste for whatever sound you are going for. The bass, treble, mid, and preamp gain are as low as you can have them and have the full sound you want. If you have to max one...nbd. But it is a guide for how to begin the shaping.
Once you have all that, introducing a clean boost or two would be what you do. (No distortion from pedal)
Then you do the final shaping to sculpt it.
That is my opinion on a marshall circuit. All im saying is try it and make the same clip. I would like to hear it
At the end, you are shaping the tone to your speakers with everything introduced and you have recording volume set. Then you could bump the distortion on the pedal if you still need more nasty. If you have to max that and the preamp gain on amp, you have the wrong amp