mesa dual rectifier stack vs marshall jcm8002203 and 1960b cab for pop punk

[bigchungusstuckinmymouth]

which is better for a pop punk/emo type of tone. i know producers like jerry finn blended them but if that’s not an option what is better

 

[Beyond Black]

IMO in almost every case a Marshall is a more appropriate amp than a Rectifier for any punk style. They’ve got more openness, kerrang and snarl.
I think Rectos are much more fitting for hardcore and metal.
Get an 800, boost it, and tear off faces.