Bugera TriRec Vs. Mesa Dual Recto (Video)

  • Thread starter Thread starter fluff191
  • Start date Start date
i like the tone of the Bugera in this clip better than the Recto...but i also know that the Recto can be dialed in to be brighter than it is here. so while i like the tone, and maybe it will turn out to be a reliable amp (at least somewhat reliable) and someone else may buy one because they cant afford a Recto that they really want (somewhat like a few people i know who bought B52 AT-100s back in the day) then so be it. Mesa will still be making money. but if they really want a Recto, then look for a decent used one. i got my slightly used Single for the price of a new Bugera Trirec...and it has all the knobs and switches i need!

either way...awesome clip as always!
 
As many many others mentioned before, I liked the Bugera
because he's a bit brighter which makes him easier to locate
in the mix.

...but honestly, I got distracted from the comparison,
cause I paid more attention to the drum programming
which was cool as hell, I wish I could do something like that :aww:



some dude":xttd1ecz said:
If Mesa moved manufacturing to China people would scream loudly, but when the Chinese counterfeit the design and undercut Mesa people rejoice at the opportunity to slit their own throats.

Thy don't need to go to china, they are already in Petaluma
soldering and wiring their amplifiers... (minute 2:30) :lol: :LOL:

 
I could get by with either honestly.
But I really admire the construction and parts used by Mesa. I love how solid their amps look and feel.

Also, two things that determines an amps validity to me how the amp sounds, and how it responds/feels under my fingers when playing.
Unlike the amps sound, I cannot take anyones word for the later. I need to experience that first hand.
 
Thanks for sharing that video. I'm a Mesa fanboy, but this makes me consider the marketing statement "hand built in Petaluma"... Not that I care that much because I find any innovation in technique fascinating.

Piero the Guitarero":byxadt88 said:
As many many others mentioned before, I liked the Bugera
because he's a bit brighter which makes him easier to locate
in the mix.

...but honestly, I got distracted from the comparison,
cause I paid more attention to the drum programming
which was cool as hell, I wish I could do something like that :aww:



some dude":byxadt88 said:
If Mesa moved manufacturing to China people would scream loudly, but when the Chinese counterfeit the design and undercut Mesa people rejoice at the opportunity to slit their own throats.

Thy don't need to go to china, they are already in Petaluma
soldering and wiring their amplifiers... (minute 2:30) :lol: :LOL:

 
Laurens":27s56pgh said:
Thanks for sharing that video. I'm a Mesa fanboy, but this makes me consider the marketing statement "hand built in Petaluma"... Not that I care that much because I find any innovation in technique fascinating.

Piero the Guitarero":27s56pgh said:
As many many others mentioned before, I liked the Bugera
because he's a bit brighter which makes him easier to locate
in the mix.

...but honestly, I got distracted from the comparison,
cause I paid more attention to the drum programming
which was cool as hell, I wish I could do something like that :aww:



some dude":27s56pgh said:
If Mesa moved manufacturing to China people would scream loudly, but when the Chinese counterfeit the design and undercut Mesa people rejoice at the opportunity to slit their own throats.

Thy don't need to go to china, they are already in Petaluma
soldering and wiring their amplifiers... (minute 2:30) :lol: :LOL:

Don't confuse hand built with hand made
Mesa builds their amp by hand in Petaluma CA.
 
D-Rock":vpwj0ba6 said:
Don't confuse hand built with hand made
Mesa builds their amp by hand in Petaluma CA.

Well, I guess I am confused. We see a robot manufacturing. Where is the hand made part coming in?
 
The difference is assembling parts together by hand vs. actually making the caps, transformers, knobs, etc. in house.
 
Laurens":3405ldgh said:
D-Rock":3405ldgh said:
Don't confuse hand built with hand made
Mesa builds their amp by hand in Petaluma CA.

Well, I guess I am confused. We see a robot manufacturing. Where is the hand made part coming in?
They are building the amps. Just like you build a house. You acquire the parts and build it by hand.
I'd take the accurate work of the robots at a mass produced level over the inconsistant time crunched hand of a human anyday. Let the humans build. Let the robots zap, turn and solder at a rate and consistancy level beyond our capabilities.
If you thought humans were actually doing the work that the robots were doing, then I really don't know what to tell you....other than wake up I guess.
 
fluff191":5a6bhhzt said:
The difference is assembling parts together by hand vs. actually making the caps, transformers, knobs, etc. in house.

Thanks, that clears it up for me!

D-Rock":5a6bhhzt said:
They are building the amps. Just like you build a house. You acquire the parts and build it by hand.
I'd take the accurate work of the robots at a mass produced level over the inconsistant time crunched hand of a human anyday. Let the humans build. Let the robots zap, turn and solder at a rate and consistancy level beyond our capabilities.
If you thought humans were actually doing the work that the robots were doing, then I really don't know what to tell you....other than wake up I guess.

I know what technology is capable of, but excuse me for not knowing to what extent Mesa is using this. And yes, I agree about the consistancy etc. Other companies are doing it differently, but I care about the end result.
 
fluff191":3qk8nnsx said:
The difference is assembling parts together by hand vs. actually making the caps, transformers, knobs, etc. in house.
Which no amp manufacturer does.... ;)
 
Heritage Softail":7vhqelty said:
Bugera sounds like unemployed Americans and Chinese theft.

Sounds very close. But counterfeits are designed to sound close.

As destroyed as the economy is, the huge number of unemployed or underemployed people that are out there...

It is amazing Americans buy this stuff. It is a pretty poison. And stealing downloaded music did not hurt any musicians either.

It doesn't matter how great of a counterfeit it is, it is like a cancer that Americans pay money to get.

If you don't understand economics well enough to understand how this hurts our economy, remember that you don't have to understand the nuclear bomb works for it to kill you.

The fact is that spending money with China is funding the friend of North Korea. Right now China is openly saying they are still backing N K even after they say they will launch a first Nuke strike on the US. They have token criticism but funnel all the supplies to them they need.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/03/10/world/asia/china-says-it-will-not-abandon-north-korea.html?_r=0

Yeah I bet those millions of Bugeras sold sure make a dent in the American economy :jerkit:

Remember American jobs are still required to sell them, so not all is lost with foreign products. Why don't you use that argument about your TV, because it certainly isn't made here. Or your car stereo, microwave, DVD player, etc.
 
lol I thought this was about tone. I had my gripes about it but you guys are just nuts. The amp is made in China. So is 90% of the goods you people buy. Get over it. The world has changed for better or worse.
 
borninwinter":2wzcb7za said:
mchn13":2wzcb7za said:
borninwinter":2wzcb7za said:
Every successful product ever produced leads to inexpensive knockoffs. And it says "Bugera" on the front, not Mesa. And it costs a grand less. I don't think anyone is fooled into thinking its a real Mesa. And if you know here is the original, here is the knockoff you have every right to make the choice, esp if you're a working musician without that extra grand to throw around. If there was some sort of legal problem, you can be sure that Mesa would come after them. But, really, Bugera poses no threat to Mesa's continued success. And whether you buy one or the other just isn't going to affect the economy.

Bullshit. Its not only our economy, but we also keep pouring money into a nation that supports...nvrmnd. Imo its about craftmanship. And something that will stand the test of time and still be worth something ten years down the road. Not this throw away garbage that keeps getting sold to us over and over. Go on about the poor guitarist that cant affford shit. Ive personally had at least two rectos that ive bought used for that price.

I'm happy for people to buy whatever amp makes them happy for whatever reason. But the US Gov't borrows literally millions of dollars every hour of every day from China. Given that, the entire amp industry is irrelevant in the big picture. I don't think that borrowing all that money is a good thing, but the issue is way bigger than buying American. Regardless, the fact is that every amp company based wherever uses at least some parts from China out of necessity. One example, try buying some new, high end US tubes. I'm not sure supporting Russia with all my tube purchases would be my choice in abstract, but I don't really have much choice in that. Just the way things are.

To your other point, craftmanship has it's value, and I choose to own higher end amps myself. But "value" can also be had in producing something that does the same job for less money. That is the free market. I really don't get this idea that it's ok to base a product on other people's designs if you make it high end, but it's unthinkable to do it to make a low end version. Like I said before, I really don't think Bugera is going after Mesa's market, but if they are so what? Say hypothetically that Bugera is as road worthy as a Mesa. If they can make essentially the same amp and stay in business selling it for a grand less, than why does Mesa always and forever have a right to charge $1800 for a certain sound. Their design did not pop out of thin air either...

As someone else said, I think the used market it another subject, since they companies making the amp are out of the picture at that point.

When the US government decides to stand up for the USA and its citizens it will encourage manufacturing in the US not outside of it. The problem is the US government is all about greed and power and is willing to sacrifice the middle class and anyone else in the way of their hunger for power and greed. Why do you think the people with big bucks have been buying gold and having it stored in other countries.
 
Solution, get out of the middle class. :P. Or move out of this country. Pretty simple. In the meantime, I'm going to enjoy all that America has to offer, including the spoils of cheap electronics that aren't made here.


Back on topic, that was a great demo vid. Not really surprised they sound that similar. I played a 6260 right next to a 6505 and although they weren't identical, they were in fact very similar. Seems Bugera amps are over the initial hump of amps catching fire. I just wonder how long they would last in the long run. I say that nimbly considering I own a MIC Jet City amp and have no fear of it breaking down.

I've heard a couple different Bugeras at shows and thought they sounded pretty darn good. I think what puzzles me the most is they basically started out as Peavey copies, yet you could get used Peavy amps for about the same price if not cheaper than the Bugera copies, and have a more reliable amp to begin with. They're still around so something must be working in their favor . . .

Again, good vid. I enjoy your vids as much as Ola's.
 
guitarmike":1pl4sgbr said:
When the US government decides to stand up for the USA and its citizens it will encourage manufacturing in the US not outside of it.
This will never happen. Greed and power won't allow it.

You vote with your dollar.
 
D-Rock":531o7b50 said:
Used Mesa for less than 1k
all
day
long.
Used Bugera for $300
all
day
long.

Seriously, these things are going to be dirt cheap on the used market. I don't even overly like the recto tone, but I'd pick one up for $300 just to dick around with.
 
Also LOL @ anyone who think "made in the USA" means it's made by "Americans". 90% of manufacturing jobs are done by immigrants. Made in the US by Mexicans and Chinese, or made in Mexico and China by Mexicans and Chinese; what's the difference, other than labour costs?
 
madrigal77":2s9i59kk said:
Also LOL @ anyone who think "made in the USA" means it's made by "Americans". 90% of manufacturing jobs are done by immigrants. Made in the US by Mexicans and Chinese, or made in Mexico and China by Mexicans and Chinese; what's the difference, other than labour costs?
The difference is where the money goes after it's paid to the workers.
 
Back
Top