Do all the Bareknuckle pickups suck or just mine?

[mchn13]

I've tried a few now and while I didn't get along with most, the miracle man is an awesome pickup! I sold it as I already had a set of JB/59 in the guitar I was trying it in and that's my favorite for that les Paul.
The miracle man screams and I'll probably get another when I buy a new guitar next year. It reminds me of an Sh-6 but maybe hotter.

 

[RJF]

I know this thread is a few months old, but I find this interesting.

I have been looking into pickups for a neckthrough maple/alder guitar, and thought maybe the Warpig would be a good solution for adding some chunk to it. It seems like it would be, but not so sure after reading this. I haven't tried any BKP, but generally I do not like anything (amps, pedals, etc...) that is described as super clear, articulate, and super dynamic.

I actually love the Nazgul I have in a different 6 string guitar (bolt on alder), so since I love the Nazgul, maybe BKP is not for me, lol.

I find many Dimarzio can be the same way... they can have tons of "bass", but not really have a good chunk to them when palm muting. I have a Tone Zone and Crunch Lab like this. I don't know what it is, but Duncans do seem to have a more thumping low end, dynamically.

Of course, now I dont know what pickup to choose.....

You will likely not like the Warpig. I disliked it so much, I don't think I have any interest in trying anything BKP at this point.