We could go over this topic for years. And for years it has done exactly that.
It lacks the number one character that made his tone what it is - a marshall being a marshall. On the brink of destruction at that. He dimed the whole damn amp to 10. Was extremely picky with the pickup that he used unlike this guy. EQ's were involved - not just mimicing the studio recording process.
There is only one user here who IMHO got the absolute closest EVH tone i have ever known - bmf5150