Yeah I guess just from my experience the ones I've played failed to live up to expectations and would be great projects but at that point I mean..... You know using modern day stuff to rebuild the old..... I get but for me I don't have the time or patience....
For me the Reissues or Customs or whatever hit the ballpark tone and well sound better as well and feel better too ...... They aren't bad
I understand what some say about the ribbon and PCB stuff but honestly the takeaway is it's more consistent from unit to unit, they retain "character" given components used are tighter than older stuff but still within a margin of error.......
And the through hole stuff such as in Fender PCB and some others use is reasonably serviceable and has been proven to be so over time and trial and error.....
IMO I get but the trade offs and the pros outweigh the cons.