Am I responsible for modifications that I did not mention in a listing?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Mark Skid
  • Start date Start date
Looks sketchy to me as well. Notice how the label corners are pulled and torn... Looks like someone removed the Custombuckers and threw-in a set of '57 Classics.

I completely agree.

That's not the only thing either, specifically, custom shop Gibson electronics work is always tighter and cleaner than that.

You can tell the heat shrink wrap has either been messed with or isn't stock either, it's NEVER that loose.

There's no way that left the custom shop with wiring work like that. It's definitely been messed with. And combined with the stickers on the pickups, I think it's safe to say those aren't the original pickups, even if they ARE custom buckers. I agree with you though, I think they're 57 classics.
 
I completely agree.

That's not the only thing either, specifically, custom shop Gibson electronics work is always tighter and cleaner than that.

You can tell the heat shrink wrap has either been messed with or isn't stock either, it's NEVER that loose.

There's no way that left the custom shop with wiring work like that. It's definitely been messed with. And combined with the stickers on the pickups, I think it's safe to say those aren't the original pickups, even if they ARE custom buckers. I agree with you though, I think they're 57 classics.
If that soldering work is Gibson Custom Shop, I am going to apply to be a Master Pickup Installer.
 
If that soldering work is Gibson Custom Shop, I am going to apply to be a Master Pickup Installer.
Dude right? Ive NEVER seen a custom shop Gibson with soldering and wiring that messy.
 
If you knew about it and did not mention it at all... you are responsible. If you were in the same position as a buyer you would feel the item was misrepresented by the seller not disclosing something like extra holes drilled into the body.

Yep... I would not be happy about that situation at all, especially on a considerable purchase.
100% agree. Sounds pretty shady, actually. Certainly isn't full disclosure. Something like that should have been revealed in the listing. Some peoples' pictures suck, and some people suck at looking at them.

I've been in this position as a buyer. People call things mint, and there's scratches all over it that don't show up in the pictures.

But, if I'm forking out big bucks for something, I ask questions. Very specific questions.
 
I'm the buyer of the guitar. I failed to take notice of added strap knob. I should have noticed it, but I didn't. I asked the seller to re-route the guitar back to him for return and refund, but he refused. He feels that "Message me with any questions or more photos" was sufficient. I sent a message that I will consider keeping it, if he's willing to renegotiate the price. It's a fine guitar, but it's been modified. The "V" tail plate points have been bent slightly upward as well. I've sent pics of the pickups to Gibson, in an attempt to see if they may have been swapped. The labels look like they were peeled-away and placed on an alternate set of pickups. I could be wrong, I'm not sure? Both pickups read 7.4 Ohm, but that doesn't tell me much. It would be nice if Gibson stamped their p/u for ID.

View attachment 100673


View attachment 100676View attachment 100679
If you are the buyer why does your thread title say this...

Am I responsible for modifications that I did not mention in a listing?​


I am a little confused?
 
If you are the buyer why does your thread title say this...

Am I responsible for modifications that I did not mention in a listing?​


I am a little confused?
He was presenting a case in which he portrayed himself as the guilty party in order to garner a more fair response among the user base of Rig Talk, to see their true opinion, without claiming he is a victim to taint said opinion.
 
From the looks of things someone may have swapped out the original custombuckers for two neck pickups if they both read 7.4K. Most bridge pickups are slight hotter than the necks in almost every case.

Return that guitar ASAP... unless you negotiate a fair settlement for your trouble.
 
If the hole is drilled clean it may be an easy fill and buff considering the guitar is natural.
Just a thought.
 
If the hole is drilled clean it may be an easy fill and buff considering the guitar is natural.
Just a thought.
I'd consider what said 3rd hole does to it's value. Yeah, sounds like TGP response, but I can't imagine that guitar was cheap. That 3rd hole, could be an expensive whoops.
 
And I’ve worked on those pickups enough to know that the don’t come off unless peeled. I rewound one recently, potted it and it was still intact. It wasn’t until I hit it with a heat gun cleaning the baseplate that it turned black from the heat gun in which I had to the peel it off. And you can see the cover was removed at some point too
 
His policy’s are irrelevant in the guitar is not as described. Reverb will side with you no question.
I find it funny that people actually think they can maintain their "own" policies on Reverb. You're at Reverb, and/or Paypal's mercy these days - they define the policies. If people think "I don't accept returns - that's my policy" holds water - good luck with that. Especially if it's not as described or important details are conveniently left out.

This jackass may have posted pics, but you know full-well he pulled a fast one not mentioning this said hole, hoping the buyer would miss it.
 
If you are the buyer why does your thread title say this...

Am I responsible for modifications that I did not mention in a listing?​


I am a little confused?
Irrelevant, but... I did not originally intent to name the seller, so I used myself as a hypothetical.
 
Quick Reverb Story.

Sold a Strat I bought mint in the same condition, also as mint.
Guy who bought it finds out the original owner had changed the middle pickup.
He wants to send it back for the full refund - east coast to west coast.
I offer to pay his local authorized dealer to bring it back to stock. Nope.
I'll toss in gas money and a lunch while they work on the guitar. Nope.
Straight cash equal to the cost of 2 pickups. Nope.

Reverb sided with him.
If I'd have listed it Excellent I would have won based on me honestly not knowing
the internal guts had been touched.
 
Back
Top