both great pieces of gear but obviously completely different uses and purposes
it's a common meme, like this guitarmalade one:
View attachment 457233
The thing is, what the average guitar player needs is
both
The modeler to woodshed at home, make decent sounding demos, and get a vague idea what a bunch of different amps and speakers sound like under a mic
And the amp to jam with real human beings, in a real room, and to learn how to control the guitar at volume on stage and with a band - which is apparently an anachronism at this point
Like towely, I think this is a situation where most people need to choose both.