Fender sues Yamaha now........ Come in, vote and voice your opinions*_*

  • Thread starter Thread starter The~Kid
  • Start date Start date

Has Fender gone to far suing Yamaha and others

  • Yes

    Votes: 22 56.4%
  • No

    Votes: 2 5.1%
  • Don't care

    Votes: 15 38.5%

  • Total voters
    39
While, I am torn on the issue, and do recognize that Fender owns the Strat... there is a question that I don't see anyone asking.

The S shape is a fairly ubiquitous design, its almost synonymous to the instrument, much like the shapes of brass instruments, or orchestral instruments, or drums, or pianos. At what point does this grow beyond the Fender Strat and just become a default electric guitar shape?


Strat and Tele shapes have been ubiquitous for decades, that's a settled issue and why FEnder wasn't able to get body shapes patented decades ago, which was still decades after the designs were created. Fender waited too long to defend their ownership, and allowed copies for decades without protecting their designs.

The other example is Rickenbacker. They vigorously defended and protected their guitar designs legally, quickly and immediately; and they still do today.

What's new now is the European Court ruling on artistic design or whatever it was....I looked it up a few days ago and posted about it, some Swedish table design and another storage furniture...they were awarded copyrights on their functional/artistic designs. This ruling was in 2025 IIRC.

I'm no legal expert, but if you look at the table and storage furniture, I don't see anything special or unique....but if I applied that to a Strat or Tele body shape I can definitely see it clearly...


Asplund v. Mio)—ruling that originality depends strictly on an author’s free and creative choices rather than functional needs or overall visual impressions.


1785678143838.png


now consider that and objectively apply that to a Strat, Tele, offset, or a Gibson Flying V....
 
Going to meet up with some old friends and hang out over dinner.


They are players too and wonder what they think about this Fender thing and the new CEO.
 
While, I am torn on the issue, and do recognize that Fender owns the Strat... there is a question that I don't see anyone asking.

The S shape is a fairly ubiquitous design, its almost synonymous to the instrument, much like the shapes of brass instruments, or orchestral instruments, or drums, or pianos. At what point does this grow beyond the Fender Strat and just become a default electric guitar shape?

Fender owns the Stratocaster name. They do not own the body shape. Nobody owns it, nobody has ever owned it. All of Fender's bodies are public domain, they belong to the people not a corporation.
 
Yeah but it in a sense one can also consider the Don't Care as a No vote as both votes don't care in regards to Fender doing this.
You tried this argument before on me, it was BS then. It is BS now.

Just because YOU may kinda consider the color of the sky like a blue-ish green, doesn't actually make it that.
Or better yet... I asked Sandra Bullock 30 years ago to marry me. She hasn't responded... But hey, she didn't say "No" either! :geek:
 
While, I am torn on the issue, and do recognize that Fender owns the Strat... there is a question that I don't see anyone asking.

The S shape is a fairly ubiquitous design, it’s almost synonymous to the instrument, much like the shapes of brass instruments, or orchestral instruments, or drums, or pianos. At what point does this grow beyond the Fender Strat and just become a default electric guitar shape?
Any non Fender Strat is a copy guitar and should be cracked down on IMO. I don’t really care tho. I roll my own with licensed parts, kinda the same as the copiers I guess. But I don’t sell them. And the Les Paul is the default guitar shape
 
Maybe everything was fine up until this Yamaha/Pacifica thing.....

But this was the turning point one can say with all this whatever the hell Fender and the new CEO is doing now :dunno:
 
Maybe everything was fine up until this Yamaha/Pacifica thing.....

But this was the turning point one can say with all this whatever the hell Fender and the new CEO is doing now :dunno:
Shut the fuck up
 
Back
Top