played the Herbert again today, as well as an Engl Fireball and Powerball II, and a Twin Jet. no longer interested in the Framus. Both the Engl's sounded so much better I kind of don't even see the point of thinking about the Framus at all. But am now stuck between the Powerball and the the Herbert. I think overall, the Powerball sounded better, way better articulation and clarity, and just a really freaking nice tone, more organic/less processed sounding than the Herbert (but not nearly as organic sounding as the Uberschall imo), and the mids really help with the overall tone, and the cutting-through aspect. problem is, for the one thing I want to do, the Herbert f*cking destroys. I don't care so much for the other two channels, especially compared to the Engls, but that one channel just KILLS. there's next to no articulation, and the midrange kind of almost isn't there even without engaging the mid cut (altho we tried putting the intensity to 0, and the level to like 3 oclock, and it actually acted as a midboost, which helped), but I've never heard anything so pummeling and evil and eviscerating in all my life. and the bass power OMFG. playing the amp with the master on about 2.5 actually gave me a stomach ache like I just watched a car wreck. There's no question that the Herbert gain channel is THE sound I want for this project. I just can't get over the price (used it's more than a new Powerball, and I found a couple used Powerball v1 for around 1300, which is about half the price of a used Herbert), and the fact that it's 180 watts, which is WAY more than I need at this point. Will likely pick up a Powerball and fiend for the Herbert. Wish I could afford both.
basically I have to decide if I want pure evil or a more broadly usable, less compressed/more dynamic gain sound. i pretty much already know the answer to that.